Demolition review
Historical Commission
Outcome, as read from the minutes:ApprovedRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
University not to demolish Smith Hall until funding has been secured, plans approved by all relevant agencies, and construction underway; preservation and maintenance of adjacent historic structures
Prior meeting reference: Architectural Committee meetings of 29 November 1990 and 18 December 1990 (special meeting at Annenberg School); designated October 1989
- Vote tally How to read this
- Motion introduced by Nathan, seconded by Wismer; Brownlee, Hollenberg, and DeLong abstained due to University affiliation
- Criteria cited
- Economic hardshipPublic interestPhiladelphia Code provisions related to demolition of historic buildingsFeasibility of alternative sitesFinancial hardship to institutionRisk of loss of research funding and faculty
Votes and testimony
Votes
How to read this- David Brownleeabstain
- David Hollenbergabstain
- DeLongabstain
- Jason Nathanyes
- Scott Wildsyes
Testimony
- Alan MacDiarmidsupport, person
- Barry S. Coopermansupport, person
- Bryan Culkinsupport, person
- David W. Christiansonsupport, person
- Edward R. Thorntonsupport, person
- Elizabeth Huntoppose, person
- George Thomassupport, person
- Gray Smithoppose, person
- Hai-Lung Daisupport, person
- Howard Kittelloppose, person
- James Collins, Jr.support, person
- James P. Colgateoppose, person
- John Blatteauoppose, person
- John Colby Parkeroppose, person
- Marna Whittingtonsupport, person
- Michael D. Hardyoppose, person
- Michael J. Lewisoppose, person
- Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
- Richard Tylersupport, person
- Robert Kohleroppose, person
- Robert Venturisupport, person
- Sheldon Hackneysupport, person
- Solomon Pollacksupport, person
- University City Historical Societyoppose, organization
- University of Pennsylvania Graduate Student Assemblyoppose, organization