Committeepeople for Ward 27, Division 5 are on the City Commissioners' list. Ward leaders are elected by their party's committeepeople. Committeepeople lists(opens in a new tab)
These are the neighborhood schools for this address. Special admission schools are not included. Report cards open on psdreportcard.com, an independent site.
Meets at Spruce Hill Community Center
257 S 45th St
Philadelphia, PA 19104; Virtual: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81135129776?pwd=TGlGMlhqdXF4Znl0UzR0QXF1SG1rdz09
Designation status and decisions from the historic property record.
18 decisions
Historic address
400 SOUTH. 40TH STREET, 400 SOUTH. 40TH STREET PHILADELPHIA PA, 400 SOUTH 40TH STREET, 402 SOUTH 40TH STREET, 400 SOUTH. 40TH STREET (WOODLAND TERRACE) PHILADELPHIA PA
Year built
2018
Building description
APTS 100+ UNITS MASONRY
Owner
OAP INC
Source links open full minutes. Exact passages have not been matched to these records.
Nomination
Document type: DC
Outcome, as read from the minutes:DeniedRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
Rescission denied; designation amended to indicate that the c. 1856 Italianate building is historically significant, but the 1960s and 1970s additions and alterations are not historically significant
Prior meeting reference: Individually designated 1 November 1973; listed on National Register as part of Hamilton Family Estate District (certified 1978); staff sprinkler system application approved 2000
Section 5.5.c.1 of the Commission's Rules & RegulationsCriteria 1 — additional information shows resource does not meet criteria for RegisterCriteria 2 — error in professional judgment at time of designationOriginal 1973 ordinance — Commission authorized to designate properties it deems historically significant
Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphianeutral, organization
Robert Powerssupport, person
Sam Olshinsupport, person
Tom Lussenhopsupport, person
Nomination
Historical Commission
Outcome, as read from the minutes:DeniedRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
Designation amended to indicate that the c. 1856 Italianate building is historically significant, but the 1960s and 1970s additions and alterations are not historically significant.
Prior meeting reference: Individually designated 1 November 1973; Committee on Historic Designation meeting 10 July 2007
University City Historical Societyoppose, organization
Alteration review
Architectural Committee
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.
Recorded conditions
House to be accurately restored as proposed; replica of curb with hair-pin fence at sidewalk line to be installed; signage at 40th and Pine Streets denied pending complete details; demolition of non-historic additions may proceed prior to construction start; all restoration details to be finalized with PHC staff
Prior meeting reference: In-concept application approved November 2007; height reduced from 11 to 10 stories since in-concept approval
Secretary of the Interior's Standard 4Secretary of the Interior's Standard 5Secretary of the Interior's Standard 6Secretary of the Interior's Standard 7Secretary of the Interior's Standard 9Secretary of the Interior's Standard 10New Additions Guidelines
Spruce Hill Community Associationneutral, organization
Alteration review
Architectural Committee
Outcome, as read from the minutes:ApprovedRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.
Recorded conditions
Three-story section on 40th Street to be redesigned to be less competitive and more compatible with the historic house; color of cladding on two appendages to be changed to a less contrasting color; Architectural Committee and staff to review details
Prior meeting reference: July 2007 rescission review; November 2007 in-concept approval; October 2008 Architectural Committee review; November 2008 Commission denial
Philadelphia City Planning Commissionsupport, organization
Ron Pattersonsupport, person
Sam Olshinsupport, person
Spruce Hill Community Associationneutral, organization
Tom Lussenhopsupport, person
Alteration review
Historical Commission
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
Three-story section on 40th Street to be designed less competitive and more compatible with historic house; cladding color on two appendages to be changed to less contrasting color; Architectural Committee and staff to review details
Prior meeting reference: November 2008 (555th Stated Meeting) — application denied; November 2007 — in-concept approval granted; July 2007 — rescission request denied; October 2008 Architectural Committee review
Criteria cited
New Additions GuidelinesSetting GuidelinesEntrances and Porches Guidelines
Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
Sam Olshinsupport, person
Sara Merrimansupport, person
Tom Lussenhopsupport, person
Unite Here!support, organization
William Burnsoppose, person
Alteration review
Architectural Committee
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.
Recorded conditions
Staff recommended approval in concept contingent on restoration of front porch and doorway to 1902 appearance. Committee members raised concerns about parapet height, front porch restoration, and setbacks. Decision was still under discussion at the point the minutes were cut off.
Prior meeting reference: Commission denied rescission of designation July 2007; Commission approved 10-story hotel building December 2008
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
Architectural Committee recommended approval in concept provided: front porch and doorway restored to 1902 appearance; parapet height reduced to minimum; Pine Street wing reduced in length; facades of new building simplified. Applicants agreed to reconstruct porch and minimize parapet but declined to reduce Pine Street wing or remove bays.
Prior meeting reference: Architectural Committee, 27 September 2011; Commission approval December 2008; Commission denial of rescission July 2007
Criteria cited
Section 14-2007(7)(k)(.4) - compatibility with character of site and surroundingsCommission approval of December 2008
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.
Recorded conditions
Architects to study roofline variation, corner articulation, details, massing, street engagement, and 'porchiness'; recommendation is advisory only
Prior meeting reference: July 2007 (rescission denied); December 2008 (10-story hotel approved); October 2011 (7-story apartment building approved in concept)
Secretary of the Interior's Standard 9Section 14-2007(7)(j) - financial hardship/cannot be used for any purpose for which it is or may be reasonably adaptedSection 14-2007(7)(k)(.4) - compatibility with character of historic district or site, neighboring structures, surroundings and streetscapeFifth Amendment takings clauseMaher v. City of New Orleans (Fifth Circuit, 1975)First Presbyterian Church of York v. York City Council (Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court, 1976)
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Prior meeting reference: Rescission denied 19 July 2007; Architectural Committee meeting 25 November 2008; Commission approval of hotel scheme December 2008; Architectural Committee meeting 27 September 2011; Commission approval of seven-story scheme 14 October 2011
Criteria cited
Section 14-2007(7)(j) of the historic preservation ordinanceSection 9.2 of the Rules & RegulationsSection 9.3 of the Rules & RegulationsSection 6.7 of the Rules & RegulationsSection 10.2 of the Rules & RegulationsMaher v. City of New Orleans (Fifth Circuit, 1975)First Presbyterian Church of York v. York City Council (Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court, 1976)Fifth Amendment of the US Constitution
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
Committee on Financial Hardship recommended finding of financial hardship and approval of demolition; Architectural Committee recommended approval in concept of new construction; full Commission discussion ongoing at point of transcript cutoff
Prior meeting reference: Committee on Financial Hardship, 24 April 2012; Architectural Committee, 24 April 2012; Commission October 2011 (approved 7-story concept); Commission December 2008 (approved 10-story hotel concept); Commission July 2007 (denied rescission of designation)
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
Request to remove condition requiring all prerequisite approvals and building permit for new construction be obtained before any demolition may commence; Committee discussed replacing with condition tying demolition to exhaustion of Commonwealth Court historic preservation appeal, and requiring Commission review of interim landscape plan
Prior meeting reference: May 2012 hardship decision (7-2 vote with one abstention approving demolition with condition); October 2014 final approval of five-story residential replacement building; 2011 approval of 7-story L-shaped apartment building; 2008 approval of 10-story hotel with connector to restored house; 2007 denial of request to rescind designation
Criteria cited
Section 14-2007(7)(j) of the historic preservation ordinance (financial hardship)Section 14-1005(6)(c) of the preservation ordinance (conditions on approval)Section 14-1005(6)(e)(.2) of the preservation ordinance (historical, architectural, and aesthetic significance)Section 14-1001(5) of the preservation ordinance (purposes: strengthen economy of City)
Outcome, as read from the minutes:No decisionRead from the minutes by software. How to read this
Recorded conditions
Request to remove condition from May 2012 hardship decision requiring building permit issuance prior to demolition; staff recommends Commission should not condition complete demolitions approved under financial hardship provision.
Prior meeting reference: May 2012 Financial Hardship decision; October 2014 final approval of new construction; Committee on Financial Hardship, 19 December 2014