Happy to do so.
And there was a little change, right? A number of units?
There was a change that had been made as of the first hearing.
Want to show us the property, too, as you can give us an update?
Yep, no problem at all.
So just to refresh the board's memory, this pertains to 216 and 218 South 42nd Street.
so let me just refresh your memory in terms of this property so um if you will recall this is a
historical property in the sense that uh the buildings were built in 1890 and 1930 it does
not have a formal historical designation but historically speaking the building was used
as six dwelling units and a photography studio for a very well-renowned photographer
That photography studio is no longer in use.
So the application that was before the board and that we presented during the first hearing was essentially to replace that longstanding photography studio with six additional dwelling units.
So that would add to the six dwelling units that already have historically existed in the building.
Now, if the board will remember during the first hearing, what we what we tried to do is present a very detailed photographic walkthrough to really show the board how complicated this building is in terms of its interior layout.
in terms of all of the stairs that not only separate the main levels,
but the stairs that separate even interior to units and even in between levels
to really try and establish to the board that the layout that we had presented to you
is really driven directly by those physical conditions of this building.
So the refusal that was originally issued was for 15 units.
By the time of the first hearing, Gabe had already worked with his architect to revise that down to 12.
So that was the layout that we had presented to the board.
And then just in addition to the physical layout that we had presented to you, we did also show you that the density is consistent with and even really less dense than many of the surrounding properties here.
We did show you a chart that shows the density per square foot, but just as a general overview,
again, you can really see here, and I don't know where the, I don't know where my actual
I don't know where my my actual densities went, but I can I can attest to you that these densities are in a lot of cases more or comparable to what is being proposed.
densities went, but I can.
So this is really a dominantly multifamily block despite the RSA three zoning.
And that was really where we had left off.
You know, we had taken a lot of time with the photo walkthrough.
And I think the board just felt like some more time was going to be needed.
so that's that's basically where we had left off at the first hearing so do you want your
testimony adopted or do you dig it he did adopt it i'm happy to have him re-adopt what i've just
shared with you so why don't you please state and spell your name for this talk uh my name is
gabriel budal levin g-a-b-r-i-e-l uh it is on yeah b-u-d-a hyphen l-e-v-i-n do you swear or
firm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth. I do. Okay. Questions from the
board. Let me just have him quickly read my testimony. Go ahead. Gabe, were you present
for and recall the testimony that was offered during the first hearing? Yes. And were you
present for the summary overview that I gave the board today? Yes. Do you agree that testimony is
true and accurate and would you adopt it as if you had given it yourself? Yes. Questions from
we're happy to answer any questions yes has there been any like changes with the rco any other
discussions any other positioning there there has there has not um gabe met with them quite a few
times and really tried to express to them you know again a lot of the similar information that we
conveyed to the board that you know having having a total of six units in the building doesn't make
any sense there's already six units having eight units in the building also doesn't make sense
given the size of the commercial space that's being replaced so i i think unfortunately um he
did reduce it from the 15 to 12 as a result of some of those initial discussions but there has
not been any update since the last meeting is that accurate yes that's accurate the questions
yeah i have a question more just about property management um this is a lot of units in one place
And it seems that there's been some community pushback.
So I think my question is, what is going to be your plan for the, like, ongoing maintenance of the building in terms of trash, you know, moving people?
There's lots of stairs and levels, secured entrances and access, and just making sure that tenants generally are, you know, doing, being good neighbors to others.
Well, I'll actually be living in the building, so I have a pretty big stake that I'll have good neighbors, you know.
I also have been managing properties in the area for almost 20 years, and I submitted letters from neighbors basically saying that they've never had noise complaints.
We pick up trash.
We do our best to be good neighbors.
We shovel snow for our neighbors.
We pick up leaves for our neighbors.
I grew up in the neighborhood.
I want to ensure the neighborhood stays as great as it is and becomes even better.
So, you know, Bad Neighbors is not in my interest, has never been in my interest.
And just a reminder in terms of the floor plans, you can see here that Gabe actually designed one of these units for himself.
This unit, by all means, is large enough that it could have been broken into two, but he is intending to live in this building.
So this unit is designed specifically for him.
And there are just in terms of trash storage, there's actually two two different trash areas in the building.
just to make sure that, you know, there's ample space for people to be able to store trash inside
of the building without relying, you know, predominantly on exterior storage as well.
Other questions? Not question, but comment. This is, I guess, you've done all you can with respect
to accessibility in terms of the number of staircases there seems to be in here?
Yeah, we can get the, the architect is on the Zoom. Unfortunately, because this is an existing
building, it's really driven by the existing conditions. So, you know, there unfortunately
are staircases everywhere you can imagine in, in, in the building from the exterior. So there's not
a whole lot that can really be done to improve those conditions. Um, but, uh, you know, I know
that, I know that it is something that the architect did look at and we can bring him on
if there's additional questions on that. Just, yeah. Building occupied now? The original six
units are occupied or how about the new ones uh no they're not occupied currently but uh they were
But they were occupied, one of which by the previous owner, who's going to be continuing to live there once we cross all these T's, not all these I's, and finish up.
occupied one of which by the previous owner who's going to be continuing
Other questions?
Questions from our attorney.
I just wanted to note for the record that there is a missing refusal for accessory off-street parking.
Thank you.
Questions or comments from the virtual audience?
I see no hands, Chair.
Planning Commission.
Hello?
Yeah, go ahead.
I'm sorry.
I'm here from the Spruce Hill Zoning Committee.
Sure, sure.
Could you please state and spell your name for this stenographer?
Yeah, Craig Santoro, C-R-A-I-G-S-A-N-T-O-R-O.
Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?
Please proceed, sir.
So my understanding is that Mr. Buda Levin met with the near neighbors, and they were
unable to come to an agreement on the number of units.
Just for context, this is where the student housing of Penn meets the long term, you know, single families of the neighborhood.
It's sort of right on the border. And yes, it is true that there are lots of, you know, multifamily dwellings on that block.
It's also true that the near neighbors feel pretty beset by that.
And the feeling is that, you know, the 15 units that were presented to us and given the 12 units that are being presented now are just too much.
And they were they're pretty steadfast.
They are steadfastly against it.
And we as the RCO are also opposed.
Thank you very much for taking the time to call us.
Is there anyone else in the virtual audience?
Anyone in the current audience here?
I see a hand by Angela Curry.
I will promote her to panelists.
Good morning.
Good morning.
Good morning.
Hi, could you please state and spell your name for the stenographer?
Angela Curry, A-N-G-E-L-A-C-U-R-R-Y.
Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?
Of course.
Are you a neighbor?
Please proceed.
I live on the 200 block of St. Mark's Square.
I have three school-age boys who have attended the near campus Parent Infant Center and the
Penn Alexander School.
My home directly abuts the units contemplated, and I just wanted to read a statement that the applicant has failed to establish a sufficient basis for treating 216 and 218 South 42nd Street as a unified use.
Based on the information presented, the two houses appear to have only one existing interior opening between them.
The mere existence of a limited connection does not by itself explain why two separate
residential structures should be combined for zoning purposes or why the requested intensity
of use is necessary.
The applicant should be required to identify the physical, functional, and legal basis for
unity of use and to demonstrate why the properties cannot continue to function a separate zoning
compliant residences. This seems right for many legal and zoning considerations that have not
been identified to date by the applicant. The applicant's explanation concerning changes in
floor elevation is likewise internally inconsistent and unsupported. Council asserted that multiple
elevation changes prevented larger dwelling spaces from being combined and therefore required
subdivision into numerous very small units, yet the applicant's own description of the existing
and proposed layouts included several units that span multiple elevation changes. If elevation
differences can be accommodated within those units, the applicant has not explained why the
same design approach cannot be used to combine other spaces and reduce the number of units.
A generalized reference to elevation changes is not substantial evidence of a hardship or of the minimum variance necessary.
Before granting relief, the board should require specific plans, measurements, and testimony identifying each alleged constraint,
explaining why reasonable design alternatives are infeasible, and reconciling the claimed limitation with the multi-level units.
and reconciling the claimed limitation with the multi-level units proposed.
The applicant and counsel have also asserted that the prior owner is living in the residence
currently. We would like to ask the applicant and counsel if that is in fact true, as no neighbor
has seen the prior owner for months. And as an aside, personally, I have witnessed the work in
construction and it has been incredibly disruptive. Yesterday was Report Card Conference Day at
Penn Alexander School and all of the Philadelphia public schools. There were huge construction
vehicles and they were impeding the ability of families to get into that school. It would be a
grave inconvenience and also not consistent with the neighborhood for the applicant to subdivide
those two units into much, much smaller units and increase the density of population there
for reasons that I'm sure my other neighbors have cited.
Thank you.
Hold on.
Counsel, do you have any questions?
No questions, but I would like to respond to a couple.
Is there anyone else in the audience?
I see no hands, Chair.
Counsel?
Thank you.
So just a couple of points of fact here.
So the neighbor mentioned that there is only one breach.
As we showed the board during the first hearing, there are actually three interior breaches
that already exist.
There is one at the street level, there is one at the first floor, and there is even
a breach at the third floor.
So these breaches, these two buildings have always historically operated effectively as
But even with that said, it is essentially irrelevant to the request that's before the
board.
because the request as you can see on the existing conditions plans is to retain the existing layout
of the existing units with the exception of unit one which is going to be broken up into a smaller
unit other than that the request is to take the commercial space that previously existed across
the street level first floor and second floor and to break that up into additional units so whether
that whether the building operates as one unit via unity of use simply because it historically
has or whether they were treated as two independent units that doesn't that doesn't materially or
substantively change the request that's before the board or the number of units and then i did
also just want to remind the board that the the neighbor mentioned that the units that are being
created are small. And I mean, that couldn't be farther from the truth. So you can see the new
units that are being created are 980 square feet, 3,335 square feet, over 1,300 square feet,
540 square feet, 500 square feet, and 840 square feet. The other units are remaining exactly in
their existing conditions, but the units that are actually being created here are quite large
in comparison to what this board often sees. So, you know, again, this really is not a situation
where Gabe has tried to chop this up into as many units as possible. This is really driven by the
layout of the existing building itself. And then, Gabe, because she made some allegations about
construction i just want to confirm were those construction vehicles yours that she's referring
to if you could address that no parking on the street permit for i think it was it was three
weeks ends the 21st but we are using a cherry picker to paint and restore the outside of the
building and we did have it break down yesterday and the company had to send out a car who parked
where he could to fix the machinery but that's been two days of us using the cherry picker but
got permits for street closure all that stuff okay thank you all right planning commission
good morning liz usually on behalf of the philadelphia city planning commission
the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing rsa3 residential single-family
attached zoning at this location the appellant has demonstrated that the condition of the property as
a converted multi-family unit is prohibitive to its reconversion back to single-family use
there is a documented history of the same use in these two properties dating to at least the 1960s
therefore the city planning commission recommends the board grant the requested
variance for multifamily household living use okay so uh i just want to talk to the board about it
all right we'll have a little conversation that'll be the wednesday we come back right which is