civus

Committee Hearing, April 2, 2003

Minutes from Philadelphia City Council Committee Hearings, Apr 2, 2003

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

00001 COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE - - - Room 696, City Hall Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Wednesday, April 2, 2003 9:55 a.m. - - - Bill Numbers 030002, 030003, 030004, 030005, 030006, 030008, 030009 030010, 030012, and 030013; -and- Resolution Number 030030 - - - PRESENT: COUNCIL PRESIDENT ANNA C. VERNA COUNCILWOMAN JANNIE BLACKWELL COUNCILWOMAN BLONDELL REYNOLDS BROWN COUNCILMAN DAVID COHEN COUNCILMAN JAMES KENNEY COUNCILMAN RICHARD T. MARIANO COUNCILMAN MICHAEL A. NUTTER COUNCILMAN BRIAN J. O'NEILL COUNCILMAN ANGEL L. ORTIZ COUNCILWOMAN DONNA REED-MILLER COUNCILMAN FRANK RIZZO COUNCILWOMAN MARIAN B. TASCO - - - V A R A L L O Incorporated Litigation Support Services 1835 Market Street, Suite 600 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 215.561.2220 215.567.2670 00002

Council President Verna

This is a continued hearing of the Committee of the Whole, regarding Bill Numbers 030002, 030003, 030004, 030005, 030006, 030008, 030009 030010, 030012, and 030013, and Resolution Number 030030. Our first department today is the Department of Records. I would ask the Commissioner to please approach the witness table. Good morning. Please identify yourself for the record and proceed with your testimony. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Good morning. My name is Joan Decker, Commissioner of Department of Records. I will not read the testimony. I think you have a written copy. I'd just like to make a couple of comments.

Council President Verna

And we will give the stenographer a copy. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Okay. I have with me today Jeanne Reedy, Administrative Services Director; Diana Perry from our mail return group; and Hector Valentin, Senior Photographer. I'd like to acknowledge their presence. 00003 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole First I would like to thank City Council members for the support of the Records Department. During the past year you enabled us to pass a C increase which will enable us to continue to provide service improvements to our customers, and also to implement a number of productivity initiatives within our department. One of the initiatives that we will be implementing will be a document recording notice program which is really designed to notify the home property owners any time a deed or a mortgage is filed in our department, to give them advance notice in the event that there is some fraudulent activity that's occurring against their property, and give them enough notice so that they can prevent any subsequent fraudulent activity from occurring. The other initiatives that we have planned include converting a lot of our land records that are used by many of the citizens into electronic format to make them more convenient and accessible to our customers. We also are looking into pursuing electronic recording where documents will be 00004 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole submitted in electronic format, reducing the amount of paper that is handled both by the submitters as well as our department, and automating a lot of the operations within the document recording area. And with that I would like to answer any questions that you may have.

Council President Verna

Thank you. How many of your employees are under the DROP program, and when will they be going out? COMMISSIONER DECKER: There are approximately ten employees in DROP.

Council President Verna

I'm sorry. I didn't hear you. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Sure. Approximately ten employee enrolled in DROP, and three of them will be going out in FY '04. There are about --

Council President Verna

So you would have eight vacancies? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct. Over a period of years, that is. Most recent enrollees occurred this past January, so we still have about two or three individuals who 00005 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole recently signed up, and it's possible that they will stay --

Council President Verna

But in your testimony you say the number of staff position changes from 90 positions to 85 full-time staff positions. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes. That's correct. That is through DROP, and also through just attrition and retirements. And we are able to do this through some of the productivity improvements that we've introduced in the department.

Council President Verna

Okay. The Chair recognizees Councilman Cohen.

Councilman Cohen

Thank you. Commissioner Decker, part of your duties involves dealing with banks and title companies; is that right? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes, Councilman, that's correct.

Councilman Cohen

And they obtain records of deed transactions of movement of property from one owner to another? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's 00006 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole correct.

Councilman Cohen

And what arrangements are made for compensation? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The --

Councilman Cohen

Do they pay for the service or is that a service the City makes available because there are benefits to the City? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The financial institutions, there are a number of mediums from which the data will be made available. And anyone who wants a computer extract of the information does pay a fee for purchasing copies of that. There are a number of companies who purchase complete copies of the microfilm that's generated from the documents that you're referencing, the deeds and mortgages and other land record transactions. So they can purchase microfilm. They can purchase electronic extracts of the information that's available.

Councilman Cohen

Now, is the same information available to the public generally on the same terms and conditions that's available to banks? 00007 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole COMMISSIONER DECKER: The microfilm and purchase of microfilm and purchase of the electronic information is available to anyone who requests it, providing that they pay the fee for the cost of making the copy.

Councilman Cohen

Now, what is the fee? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The fee is -- The microfilm is purchased through a vendor, so the vendor really is... I don't have the exact fee. It's actually -- The copies of microfilm are produced by a company. We make one copy available to that company. And any companies that are any of our customers, the financial institutions which you're referencing that are interested, contract directly that company to produce a copy of the microfilm, and the company sets the fee for the copy of the microfilm produced.

Councilman Cohen

Do you mean the City doesn't furnish anything to the banks, that the banks have to deal with an outside company to get City records? COMMISSIONER DECKER: If they want a 00008 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole microfilm copy of the actual record.

Councilman Cohen

Well, I don't know whether they need a microfilm copy. Whatever copy -- Whatever material they need. Let's not get technical so that later if a question comes up you say: Well, my answer was only with respect to microfilm. I didn't know you were referring to that -- to something else. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Sure.

Councilman Cohen

What I'm concerned about is, we've been getting complaints that the public does not have available to it the same information that banks and title companies routinely get. And for years commissioners of record have said: This is about to change; we're going to make everything available so that the public can get information about real estate transactions. Maybe we could stop some of these improprieties that have taken place over the years. Whatever the reason is, it's public information. And we understand from complaints 00009 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole received -- we may be wrong; we're not making a judgment about it -- but the complaint is made that the banks and title companies receive favorable treatment that's not available to the public, and that these records are not easily available to the public. And it would seem to me that if that allegation is true, then it's a serious matter. If on the other hand, it's not true and records are made easily available, then it may be a problem of not getting out the right information to people. So, could you comment on that? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes.

Councilman Cohen

Can you tell us whether the public has these records as available on the same basis as those companies that need these services for their professional purposes? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes. All of the information that the Records Department has that is public record is available to everyone and anyone, whether they are company or an individual citizen.

Councilman Cohen

Right. So that 00010 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole any complaints we get, for example, that somebody who wants to make available on a web site the information. You're saying that that person, if he has complained about not having the same advantage as banks and real estate is wrong? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The information is available on site in City Hall to anyone and everyone. And I'm sorry to be technical, but there are different ways of producing the information and making it available. And I'll step through three ways, if you would bear with me.

Councilman Cohen

I'm sorry. I'm having great trouble hearing you. If you would speak directly in the microphone your voice will come back. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Is this better?

Councilman Cohen

Well, say a few more words. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Okay. The information --

Councilman Cohen

Yes; better. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Thank you. 00011 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole All of the information that the Records Department has is public information -- if it is public information, it's made available to everyone, whether it's --

Councilman Cohen

It's made available... Then I missed the next word. COMMISSIONER DECKER: And there are different ways of making it available. And there -- Let me step you through three ways. Companies and individuals can purchase copies of recorded records for the land records, which I think is what you're referring to, that are on microfilm. That's available to everyone. There is also --

Councilman Cohen

At no charge? COMMISSIONER DECKER: No. That's paid through a company. A company --

Councilman Cohen

Why does the company have rights? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Because we do not have the resources to produce that volume in-house, and the company was awarded the contract based on an open competitive bid.

Councilman Cohen

What sort of -- 00012 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Can you outline the nature of the contract? Is it $50, or $100, or $1,000, or $10,000? COMMISSIONER DECKER: It's based on the cost of a reel of tape, and it may be somewhere in the ballpark of $10 or $11 per reel. And I can get back to you with the exact figure.

Councilman Cohen

$10 per $11 per what? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Per reel, per reel of microfilm.

Councilman Cohen

And how many properties -- information about how many properties would be contained on a reel? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I would say a week's worth of data may include anywhere from three to five reels, depending upon the volume of documents that we've recorded in that week.

Councilman Cohen

And about how many properties would it cover? COMMISSIONER DECKER: We -- About -- I think deeds is -- the reel contains all land records. So, that would include deeds and mortgages, any kind of land record that was filed for a particular property. We record in the 00013 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole vicinity of 200,000 documents on an annual basis. We can get the math. 200,000 divided by 52 weeks.

Councilman Cohen

Can we get the information for the purpose of this hearing? It doesn't help to us have you send a letter telling us what the information is. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Sure.

Councilman Cohen

Because then we can't ask you any questions and get clarification about things. COMMISSIONER DECKER: We process 200,000 -- approximately 200,000 documents on an annual basis, divided by 52 weeks, is about 4,000 transactions a week. So someone who is purchasing a week's worth of data, which could be anywhere from three to five reels, at $10 a reel, would be $30 to $50, I would imagine. And --

Councilman Cohen

Well, has the City ever decided that it ought to make that information public directly? COMMISSIONER DECKER: It is available in our public service rooms in City Hall every day, Monday through Friday. 00014 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Cohen

How is it available? COMMISSIONER DECKER: We --

Councilman Cohen

Somebody can come in and look at the records? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes. Yes, sir. We have a number of staff who assist customers, and we also have a number of public service terminals.

Councilman Cohen

Now, do banks use that technique of getting their information? COMMISSIONER DECKER: They use a combination of techniques. Some use --

Councilman Cohen

They use a what? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Combination of methods of acquiring the data. They send searchers into our department on site. They additionally purchase copies of microfilm of the recorded transactions. They also purchase electronic extracts of the electronic index, the index of information that gives you index information about the actual copy of the document.

Councilman Cohen

Companies use 00015 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole that for purposes of their business; and they make money on it, right? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Cohen

Now, suppose -- does the City of Philadelphia make that material available so that someone sitting at home with a computer can access that material? COMMISSIONER DECKER: If they want to purchase the electronic index, yes.

Councilman Cohen

Well, would that be -- Would that make sense? Wouldn't that be very costly if they wanted to keep track of every transaction that occurred? How costly would that be? COMMISSIONER DECKER: They would have to do some programming to make that usable for them, that's correct.

Councilman Cohen

Well, then it would be quite expensive, wouldn't it? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes.

Councilman Cohen

For some individual who, say, was concerned about stories of favoritism that might exist with respect to any 00016 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole number of things, with respect, say, to assessments by the Board of Revision of Taxes. Somebody might want to check out is it true. You know, we have political organizations which in turn are run by committee people. And committee members often will report to the ward leader that in doing their work contacting neighbors, handling problems for them, one charge is frequently made that same neighbor down the street is getting preferential treatment. And that may or may not be true. Nobody knows. It would be good if there were some way of accessing that material and correcting misinformation or correcting the situation if it needs correction. How can that be done if the City doesn't make that material available to people directly through their computers? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Councilman, we do not have assessment data. That data belongs to the Board of Revision of Taxes.

Councilman Cohen

Say that again. I didn't get that. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The Records 00017 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Department does not have tax assessment information. That information is really from the Board of Revision of Taxes. It's not the Records Department.

Councilman Cohen

Well, suppose somebody wanted to check. They were told their house was bought by a slum lord who's well known in the City and who does not take care of his property. And they want to find out did that empty house down the block that was boarded up that recently sold, has it been sold to a slum lord. How would that be found out easily by the public? COMMISSIONER DECKER: They could come into the Records Department and look up the owner of the property. If they know the property address, they could come into the Records Department, use the terminals there, or ask our staff, public service staff, to assist them to look up the owner of the property.

Councilman Cohen

And there would be no fee charged? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Not to 00018 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole retrieve and view the information, that's correct, there is no fee.

Councilman Cohen

All right. Then are you saying broadly -- Tell me if I'm right or wrong with my conclusion or vary it, if you feel it needs variation. You're saying that material is made as easily available to the public as it is to anyone else. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The information exists in the system, and that system is available in the Records Department. We are open Monday through Friday. Viewing the information is available at no cost to the public.

Council President Verna

Councilman Rizzo has a point of information, Councilman Cohen.

Councilman Rizzo

Councilman Cohen?

Councilman Cohen

Yes.

Councilman Rizzo

Will you recognize me for a Point of information?

Councilman Cohen

If it's truly a Point of Information, yes.

Councilman Rizzo

It truly is. It's enlightening. 00019 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Cohen

Go ahead. I yield.

Councilman Rizzo

I just want to follow up on...

Councilman Nutter

Councilman, did you ask if it was a Point of Information, or a Point of Inquiry or a Point of Order?

Councilman Cohen

Well, I'm not sure which it is but it's --

Councilman Rizzo

All of three.

Councilman Cohen

-- it's a point.

Councilman Nutter

Defer to the Councilman's opportunity to speak.

Councilman Rizzo

It's all three. Why would this not be -- Why wouldn't this information be available on the internet? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The information is not available on the internet -- to -- We have... The system that was developed for this information requires a number of licenses to deploy it widely. And it also requires a certain network capacity to open up to a broad audience. And we are not in a position at this point in time 00020 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to deploy it on a wide -- the internet application on a wider basis.

Councilman Rizzo

Because of all the departments that have information on using technology, you would think the Records Department would be the most automated of all, because people like Councilman Cohen would like to get information. Tell me: Is there an opportunity to get this any other way from... through the internet, through another department, through L&I? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Well --

Councilman Rizzo

Is there another way in? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The information that we have, the application that is used on the internet is also available in our public service rooms in City Hall. So it's a very user friendly automated system that is open to the public. Anyone can come in to view the information

Councilman Rizzo

Commissioner, that was fine 20 years ago. People don't come in to the Public Information Office to look up an 00021 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole address like Councilman Cohen just addressed. Are you telling me that this is something we can do? And if we can't -- If you can, then tell us what you need to get it accomplished, because we need to really get up to speed on making technology and information available to people. So explain to me what you need to do. And I'm finished, Councilman Cohen. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Okay.

Councilman Rizzo

What you need to accomplish that. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The deployment on a wider basis would require a larger network capacity to come in to access the information, and also the procurement of additional licenses to make that available, based on a larger number of users who would access that information.

Councilman Ortiz

Madam Chair, if I may follow up.

Councilman Cohen

As a former Commissioner of Records, I yield to Councilman Ortiz.

Council President Verna

The Chair recognizes Councilman Ortiz. 00022 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Ortiz

Thank you, Madam Chair. What is PHILADOCS? COMMISSIONER DECKER: PHILADOCS is the automated recording system. So, it's an automated system that enables the Records Department to process documents that need to be recorded as part of the Recorder of Deeds Office.

Councilman Ortiz

If I'm an individual that runs a real estate firm and I need to check on certain things, is that available to be at my office? COMMISSIONER DECKER: There is limited access to approximately 50 companies that is available. That access is available to high usage users.

Councilman Ortiz

So you make this off center, out of office service that you can do within your -- remotely from your own office, available to 50 companies. Could you tell me, do you have a list of the 50 companies? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I could get that to you, Councilman. 00023 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Ortiz

And do you charge these 50 companies anything for it? COMMISSIONER DECKER: A pilot -- When we implemented an automated system, the year after we implemented the automated system, we --

Councilman Cohen

Could you speak into the microphone, please. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Sorry.

Councilman Cohen

When you speak into the microphone, I hear you without any problem; but as soon as you vary away from it, your voice gets lost. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Sure. Is this better?

Councilman Cohen

Yes, much better. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Okay. When we implemented the automated recording system, a year after the implementation, we produced a pilot that was -- we had a limited number of licenses that were available to make this information available, so we wanted to test that pilot. To expand -- And let me also --

Councilman Ortiz

My question was: You have 50 companies that you make this available 00024 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to. One, I'd like to see the list of those companies.

Council President Verna

Commissioner, I think the gentleman that you're looking for is right behind you. COMMISSIONER DECKER: I'm sorry.

Councilman Ortiz

One, I'd like to see the list of those companies, who they are; and two, do you charge those 50 companies anything for the service? COMMISSIONER DECKER: No, we do not. This was envisioned to be a pilot, Councilman.

Councilman Ortiz

But they get it for free? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Mm-hmm.

Councilman Ortiz

50 big companies? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I don't know that they're all big companies. But can I add a little bit of context to this, please?

Councilman Ortiz

You can add context to it, but just get a service for free that is not available to citizens of Philadelphia when it should be. And other citizens that want to access that service have to come in to City 00025 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Hall and then pay a very large fee for that. COMMISSIONER DECKER: No. No, Councilman. The companies generally in order -- The companies that are engaged in title insurance business or financial institutions that are engaged in recording mortgages and other kinds of mortgage-related instruments, generally establish title plants. And they generally establish folders of records with transactions against particular properties.

Councilman Ortiz

I know what title companies do. I'm an attorney. This is a service that should be provided to people, citizens, that want information about what real transactions are happening. If a citizen is only concerned as to what is going on in his or her neighborhood, for example: A few houses have been bought, boarded up; nobody knows who did it; and they left there; all of a sudden another house happens. And a citizen gets concerned. And he may not want or she may not want to come down or cannot come down 00026 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to City Hall. He should be able to get into a computer and access that information. If it is available to these companies, it should be available to that citizen. COMMISSIONER DECKER: And it is available. If an individual is not able to come into the department, we respond to mail requests, we respond to telephone requests.

Councilman Ortiz

But you see what I'm talking about.

Councilman Cohen

Do these companies have to do the same thing? They mail in a request for each item of information they want? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes, we do. Yes, we do.

Councilman Cohen

No, I didn't ask whether you do. I said, is it a requirement of your office that each of these 50 companies mail in separately each request?

Councilman Ortiz

No. They can access immediately, right? COMMISSIONER DECKER: They generally establish a title plan. And the online system is 00027 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole of use to them only to see the last -- latest transaction of record. All of the companies that generally do business with us -- Having the internet in itself is --

Councilman Cohen

I'm not getting your voice at all. Could you speak directly into the microphone. When you do, there's no problem at all hearing you. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The companies that need this information also purchase the information. They establish a file of data. They purchase microfilm, and they also purchase electronic extracts.

Councilman Cohen

Does the City make a profit on what's purchased from them? COMMISSIONER DECKER: No, sir. We do not make a profit.

Councilman Cohen

All right. So that the City gains nothing except they get paid the costs? Why does the City charge a fee, to cover what? COMMISSIONER DECKER: To cover the cost of producing a copy.

Councilman Cohen

The City's costs. 00028 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes, Councilman.

Councilman Cohen

It's my understanding of the law that the City is limited in its charges to recouping the cost. Now, what would be the cost of preparing it so that people in the public who may not want it to be known that they're checking on something. If there's public information, it means people have a right to check on it without making an announcement to the world that they are checking on the certain property. They ought to be able to check it, decide whether or not they want to release information that makes it clear to everybody else that this is a problem that needs attention. They may just want to look at it; say, oh, it's okay, and forgot about it. Why should they have to write so that you can notify the homeowner, or the owner of the property, or the title company that somebody's checking on something? COMMISSIONER DECKER: They don't 00029 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole need to -- They can come into the Records Department Monday through Friday --

Councilman Cohen

But citizens don't come in. Why do you erect such a barrier? Why don't you tell the realties, 50 companies, that you're eliminating them from remote access, and any information they want they're going to have to get by coming in? You don't do that because it's not convenient to the companies. And we say that's okay. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The company --

Councilman Nutter

Point of Inquiry.

Council President Verna

Excuse me. The Chair recognizes Councilman Nutter for a Point of Inquiry.

Councilman Nutter

Thank you. Councilman Cohen, are you all right with that?

Councilman Cohen

Yes. Sure. Go ahead.

Councilman Nutter

Commissioner Decker, you have and continue to be -- You have been and continue to be one of the stars in this 00030 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Administration. You and your staff, I believe, have moved the Records Department leaps and bounds over the years, from a technology standpoint, from an efficiency standpoint, from a management standpoint. And I think many of us, including those who are asking questions, have praised your work and your service. As we continue to move into this age of increasing technology and increasing access, I wondered, based on the questions that are being asked, whether or not you would be agreeable to -- And I know we have our Budget Director here who is possibly the highest ranking member of the Administration -- Well, I don't want to get into that. I think, actually, commissioners outrank budget directors, but they never get what they want. Is it possible for us with a number of Council Members who are asking questions, and the President or representative from the President, to sit down and talk about all of these issues and seek to come to a reasonable resolution 00031 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to the increasing need for access to public information by regular citizens, as well as business people, and talk through who's paying for what or who's getting access for what? And to some extent get you out of a complete negotiation right here at the table, where you might not have all of the information that you need to do what you need to do under the circumstances? Would you be amenable -- COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes. Thank you very much.

Councilman Nutter

-- to that kind of process and procedure, working in conjunction with members of Council and the Administration? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes. We'd be very happy to do that.

Councilman Cohen

But Councilman, I won't at this point be amenable to that.

Councilman Nutter

Councilman Cohen, I assume you're going to continue to ask all your questions

Councilman Cohen

No. No, not necessarily. You have a very interesting idea. But before I feel that question would be 00032 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole appropriate, we have here today a person who makes it his public business, his participation in the City affairs, things we'd like to see many other citizens do. He makes available, at the expense to himself, certain public information which I think the City itself ought to make available. But since the City doesn't, I would like to know whether or not before -- May we hear from him to see whether or not what his view would be on this, and whether we're dealing with the issues. He makes available things publicly that often I don't like, and I fight with him. You know, all of us in public life kind of feel we wanted a lot of publicity in everybody else's business. But when it comes to things we're involved in, we like to assert privacy. So I have any own disputes with the gentleman involved. But basically he's doing a very useful public service. He makes available, whether we in public life like it or not, things that he feels are important to the public. And when they are public issues, I think he's dead 00033 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole right. So I would like to suggest, Madam President, if we could hear from Ed Goppelt, I think his name is, who makes information available to citizens of Philadelphia on a web site, public information that's clearly public but that the City does not make available easily. I'd like to ask whether he thinks such an arrangement would be useful. If so, I would be happy to accept Councilman Nutter's suggestion. But I feel he's the expert in this area, and I would like him to be participating in any negotiations. Is it all right, Madam President? Could he be called while commissioner Decker is -- so we know we've joined the issue.

Council President Verna

That would be fine.

Councilman Cohen

Mr. Goppelt, would you come forward. Commissioner, stay at your desk, at your seat. Can we have the Sergeant-at-Arms provide a chair?

Council President Verna

There is a chair. 00034 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Cohen

There is a chair.

Council President Verna

Yes.

Councilman Cohen

Well, identify yourself for the record, Mr. Goppelt. Spell your last name, so that they'll have it, and tell us your reaction.

Mr. Goppelt

Okay. Good morning, City Council. Councilman Cohen, can you hear me?

Councilman Cohen

Yes. Fine.

Mr. Goppelt

Okay. I'm Ed Goppelt. My last name is spelled G as in George, o double p as in Peter e-l-t as in Thomas. And I run the good government web site, hallwatch.org.

Councilman Cohen

Has the discussion that's taken place reflect consideration of your concerns? Have we been dealing with the issue as you see it or do you want to rephrase what you think is not being made available to the public?

Mr. Goppelt

Well, clearly, PHILADOCS is not being made available to the public.

Councilman Cohen

What was that again? 00035 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. Goppelt

PHILADOCS.

Councilman Cohen

Will you explain what that is.

Mr. Goppelt

It's information about deeds, mortgages, real estate transactions that is available to the title companies, to a select group of title companies, law firms, and banks. My concern about this arrangement is that it's not fair, services being provided to private companies that is not being made available to the public. I think one relevant fact which hasn't been brought out at this point is, at least according to the Records Department's previous budget messages, they implemented this so-called pilot just about three years ago. Now, I don't know about the Records Department, but it usually takes me about two days to test a web page to see whether it works or not, and they've had three years. So I think the question has to be asked: At what point is enough enough? And are you either going to go with this thing full bore and make it available to the public, or stop 00036 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole giving these companies a special break. It's not fair.

Councilman Cohen

Would you have a comment to that? I'll adopt that as my question, Mr. Goppelt. With your permission, I'd like to appropriate your question and make it mine, and ask the Commissioner for her response. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Sure. And Councilman, on advice of counsel, since Mr. Goppelt has filed a lawsuit against the City and is suing the City, I really would prefer not to answer this in a public session, but I'd be more than happy to answer all of your questions in a meeting with City Council.

Councilman Cohen

Well, unfortunately, City Council has a legislative chore to do; and the fact that somebody sues or doesn't sue is of no relevance to us. We don't think that insulates the material from public intrusion by City Council. We don't think you can employ a lawsuit against your department as an excuse to deny Council the information it must have. So we don't recognize that or else 00037 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole every department in the government would easily arrange to have lawsuits filed against it, because nobody likes to testify before City Council.

Councilman Ortiz

The question is simple. The pilot has been in effect for three years. Why doesn't it become a program? I think the issue is simple. The pilot has been in effect for three years. Why this program has not been expanded so that the public can have access to it? COMMISSIONER DECKER: And I mentioned that we do not have -- Again, I'm going against the advice of counsel. This is a suit that's filed --

Councilman Cohen

Who is counsel? And who does he represent?

Councilman Ortiz

The issue is, what information is going to be made available to the public that is made available to a private company under the guise of a pilot program that is now three years old. Now, to me that is not a pilot program any longer. That is a program. That is a program that is ongoing. And a pilot program does not take that long to be done. 00038 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole And how long is it going to be made available for free to the companies, and the citizens are made to come down to City Hall to go through that expense, and then to pay something else other, and go through all that inconvenience to get that same service. I don't think it's fair. The answer is yes or no. When is it going to be done? Is it going to be done within the next month, or the next week, the next six months, the next year? COMMISSIONER DECKER: As I previously --

Councilman Cohen

Who is the attorney advising you? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Joe Bradica from the City's Law Department.

Councilman Cohen

What's the name? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Joseph Bradica.

Councilman Cohen

Of the Law Department. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes, the City's Law Department.

Councilman Cohen

Okay. 00039 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole COMMISSIONER DECKER: As I mentioned previously, the wider deployment is based on license issues and some network capacity.

Councilman Cohen

Where's Councilman Ortiz. He raised that question. Councilman Ortiz.

Council President Verna

Councilman Ortiz.

Councilman Cohen

We received an answer. Do you want to comment on the answer?

Council President Verna

Councilman Ortiz.

Councilman Ortiz

Yes, ma'am.

Councilman Cohen

You received an answer to your question. Is it a satisfactory answer or not?

Councilman Ortiz

I didn't hear it.

Councilman Cohen

Could you repeat your answer? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Would you like me to repeat it?

Councilman Cohen

Yes. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The wider deployment of the internet application is based on 00040 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole two items: On license issues procuring the number of licenses, and also on network -- City network capacity.

Councilman Ortiz

Explain that license issue. Because a citizen -- a citizen -- certain real estate transactions is going on around him. Houses are being sold. He doesn't know to whom they're being sold to. And he wants to really -- He's concerned, because it's his neighborhood. And he wants -- He knows that there's PHILADOCS program and pilot program that companies -- real estate companies can go into and find out who is doing what in buying of properties. And he doesn't have the time to come down, but he wants to find out. Does he have to get a license? COMMISSIONER DECKER: No, Councilman. Neither the public -- members of the public nor anyone who uses this on the outside do not need to procure a license.

Councilman Ortiz

Well, you're talking about licensing. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The City has 00041 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to purchase a certain number of database licenses. The database product that the system is built around has license issues. You purchase a license based on a number of users. If you increase the number of users, you must increase the number of licenses. that --

Councilman Ortiz

So you now have a license for 50 users. COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Ortiz

And you need a license for --

Councilman Cohen

Who is using a license? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The automated systems have data bases that are part of the automated system. So whenever a system is developed, there is software that accompanies --

Councilman Ortiz

How much is that license for 50 people? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I don't have the figure with me right now. It's thousands. It would be thousands of dollars. 00042 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Rizzo

Point of Information, Councilman.

Councilman Cohen

Your point is recognized by me.

Councilman Rizzo

Commissioner Decker. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes.

Councilman Rizzo

You have 50 people that are in a pilot program. COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Rizzo

I'm a guy that likes to keep it simple. Why can't we make Hallwatch 51? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Again, we have a limited number of licenses.

Councilman Rizzo

I'll get one of those folks to give up their subscription or their... whatever. Honestly, Commissioner, it just sounds like there's more to this than we're hearing today. I can't understand why we can't make this information available to a credible organization that provides a unique service to the 00043 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole residents of this region. I'd like you to have the technology people or whoever answer the question why we can't add one more person to this issue, one more organization. Could you get someone to answer that question? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I will.

Councilwoman Brown

Madam President, May I?

Councilman Cohen

I still have the floor.

Council President Verna

The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Brown.

Councilman Cohen

Okay.

Councilwoman Brown

Thank you, Councilman Cohen. This new procedure, was it this way at the door, what we viewed to be an inequity in the process? When the program started three years ago, was it structured in such a way where citizens had to pay and businesses did not? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The pilot was made available when it was implemented several years ago to companies. 00044 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilwoman Brown

To companies. COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct. This is -- And I understand your basic point, the point that you're trying to make. This setup is not unusual across recorders' offices and other counties. The composition of your customer base is such that probably more than 90 percent of our users, 90 percent of our transactions, are really transactions that are filed by companies, including such companies like title insurance companies, banks, mortgage institutions, other kinds of financial institutions. They generally submit documents in bulk. They perform title searches against properties. So there is a rationale behind why things are structured in a certain way. And again, I understand the point that you're all making --

Councilman Cohen

What was the --

Councilwoman Brown

Those are the very types of businesses that are in the best position to pay for that type of service. 00045 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole COMMISSIONER DECKER: And they do pay for -- They purchase copies of microfilm and copies of the electronic index. They are paying and procuring other -- the information in other formats. The internet on its own is not going to enable them to conduct the business that they want. We deal -- As I mentioned, our customer base is predominantly large groups of companies.

Councilman Cohen

I thought your main customer base would be the public. Isn't that who you're supposed to be serving? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The customer -- The companies generally perform --

Councilman Cohen

You mean you're not concerned about serving the people of Philadelphia? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Of course we are. We have a number of public service terminals and a number of public service rooms that are open every day to citizens. We --

Councilman Cohen

And you think 00046 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole that's enough for them, but you're always open to make changes for the convenience of these private companies and law firms. COMMISSIONER DECKER: The companies and law firms are actually -- Their customers are members of the public. They are representing --

Councilman Cohen

Who could be more important a customer than a citizen of the City of Philadelphia? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The citizens are very important, and we do -- we service a lot of the companies --

Councilman Cohen

Why do you put such obstacles in the way? COMMISSIONER DECKER: We're not putting obstacles, Councilman.

Councilman Cohen

Why would Mr. Goppelt have this complaint? COMMISSIONER DECKER: All of our information is available to the public. That's what we do. We're in the business of making public information available to the public. We have been complimented by the state legislature for the availability of the 00047 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole records and the turnaround time that we provide.

Councilman Cohen

Because they probably don't understand that you're denying the citizens of Philadelphia the information. COMMISSIONER DECKER: We are providing the services. As I am stating, these --

Councilman Cohen

But not the kind of services that are needed. Mr. Goppelt, on his own without charging the public, is giving the public a valuable new information service. And it seems to me that you're finding every justification to try to say the people that deserve this information are the 50 companies, including the law firms that make money out of it, but that even though you're a City agency, you don't feel obligated to make that information easily available to the public. COMMISSIONER DECKER: No, Councilman. I'm definitely not saying that. Our function is to make public records available. And we do -- we do very much fulfill that mandate. We are very concerned about the citizens in the City. All of our staff -- 00048 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Cohen

Then what is your objection to making the information available to Mr. Goppelt that he spoke about? Why can't you make that information -- COMMISSIONER DECKER: Mr. Goppelt has requested a number -- the information in various formats, and he is not willing to pay the fee that other citizens and companies are --

Councilman Cohen

But he's not making a -- You mean you don't understand that he's servicing the people of Philadelphia without cost to the City? And you're saying to him, you've got to be -- find a way to make money before we're going to let you service the people of Philadelphia? COMMISSIONER DECKER: We cannot produce services at no cost. There is a cost to us. The other companies that want to procure -- The other companies and individuals that want to purchase microfilm or electronic records, they pay the fees that are involved.

Councilman Cohen

But -- And you want the people of Philadelphia have to pay an additional load of taxes, citizens of Philadelphia 00049 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole are subject to, you want them to pay an extra fee in order to be able to get public information from your department. Is that what you're saying to us? COMMISSIONER DECKER: No, sir.

Councilman Cohen

Because Mr. Goppelt does not charge the public for the use of his web site. COMMISSIONER DECKER: No, Councilman. That's not what we're saying. We're very interested in -- COUNCIMAN COHEN: Well, that's the way it's coming out.

Councilman Rizzo

Councilman Cohen, may I?

Councilman Cohen

I'll yield.

Councilman Rizzo

Commissioner Decker --

Councilman Cohen

I'm just having great difficulty in understanding why, when it comes to public information, the public is being denied that information.

Councilman Rizzo

Commissioner, if you're not willing to share this information with 00050 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Hallwatch, then why don't you just tell us today. You indicated how pleased the House of Representatives to the State Legislature is. If you want your Council to be happy with you, why don't you make this available so we don't need to give it to Hallwatch? Why don't you just make it available through the internet? Do what you need to do. I honestly think there's no -- there's no intelligent rhyme or reason here to deny this information. You have 50 people that you're giving -- From what I understand -- correct me if I'm wrong -- there are 50 people that are provided the same information at no cost in a pilot program that Mr. Goppelt wants, Hallwatch wants. There's no intelligent rationale here not to provide this organization that information, other than you don't want them to have it. Maybe it embarrasses certain agencies in this government. Shame on them. Occasionally they need it, and so do some of the elected officials. 00051 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole But I can tell you: To give this guy a workout, to give this organization a workout and make them have to go and take a lawsuit to me is, from what I know of this organization, it's unjustified. And like I said, why don't you just make it 51 people in the pilot and be done with this. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Okay. We'll be happy to do that.

Councilman Rizzo

You're going to make 51 people in the pilot? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes.

Councilman Rizzo

And we're done with it. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes.

Councilman Rizzo

He's got the information, withdraws the lawsuit? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Mm-hmm.

Councilman Rizzo

Fine. Thank you, Commissioner.

Council President Verna

The Chair recognizes you.

Mr. Goppelt

Would that it were 00052 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole that simple, Councilman Rizzo. I certainly would appreciate being added to PHILADOCS. But I have also requested the electronic version of the recorders index. And that has -- We have run into problems of cost. The Records Department has -- says that they want $400 for this information. I followed the same steps on my home computer that I believe the Records Department would have to follow in theirs. And it took less than two minutes for me to do. Maybe two lines of computer code and one CD. So I estimate that the cost to be $1.74, less than $2.00. So where is this $400 figure coming from? I have asked the Records Department or suggested on several times that we get together to discuss a fair price for these records, for the electronic version of the recorders index, and all of my offers have been rebuffed, both by Commissioner Decker, as well as the Law Department. I mean, I would be happy to meet with these folks. But every time I offer it, I 00053 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole hear nothing back, nothing.

Councilman Cohen

Because apparently the Law Department, as well as the Commissioner wants the public information to be held privately by a select group of people. We don't know why they permitted these particular 50. We might have to go into that at some point. But we don't understand why they're posing this. Are you hiding things? It's hard for me to believe that, because Commissioner, as Councilman Nutter and others have remarked, we do like your records generally. And we're stunned to learn of this problem that developed. It was so inconsistent with the record of performance that you've established for yourself in this office. We don't think you have a right -- and I'm going to ask that the lawyer for the City come to the table as soon as we're finished here, because I would like to know whether he's advising a City agency that it does not have to answer questions by City Council. Because that would be very interesting if the City Solicitor's Office wants to protect agencies from questioning 00054 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole publicly by City Council. And if that's his purpose, I would like to know that so we can deal with that situation. Could we have the attorney, Madam President, come to the desk and identify himself?

Council President Verna

He's approaching the table, Councilman. Please identify yourself for the record.

Mr. Bradica

My name is Joseph Bradica. I work in the Commercial Litigation Unit at the City of Philadelphia Law Department. Councilman, I did not advise Miss Decker not to answer your question. I advised her not to answer a question from a plaintiff of an active lawsuit against the City Records Department.

Councilman Cohen

I adopted his question as my question, sir.

Mr. Bradica

And that's fine. And once you did that, Commissioner Decker did indeed answer that question.

Councilman Cohen

All right. Thank 00055 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole you for clarifying that.

Councilman Cohen

And I believe she did that. I believe she did, in fact, answer that question.

Mr. Bradica

Once the question was adopted from you, sir, yes, sir, she did indeed --

Councilman Cohen

Yes,

Mr. Bradica

-- answer that question.

Councilman Cohen

That's my understanding.

Mr. Bradica

I would like to state, while I have this opportunity --

Councilman Cohen

I just want to have it clear on the record as to what your advice was on behalf of the Law Development.

Mr. Bradica

Yes, sir.

Councilman Cohen

And I accept that.

Mr. Bradica

Thank you.

Councilman Cohen

Thank you. I don't understand why we're having this problem, Miss Decker. You may be excused, 00056 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole attorney, or you can stay with your client, either way. I don't understand why we're having this problem, why you don't say that since he's making information available to the public, of course we'll work with him and give him the same privileges and rights that you're giving these 50 people or companies or lawyers or whoever they may be, when he is acting on behalf of the public interest, something I think you should be looking for and you should be thankful that there's something doing it without charging the City for that service, because he is servicing the informational needs of the public without taxes, without charging anything to anybody in the City. Is there anybody else who makes the decisions in the Department of Records other than you? I'm wondering why we don't get a reply from you. COMMISSIONER DECKER: I'm sorry. Are there other -- anybody else that makes decisions? It depends on the nature of the decision, that I would check some issues with the Law Department and whatever other entity might be 00057 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole appropriate in the decision-making process.

Councilman Cohen

Well, tell me on this one. It seems to me you have full authority to make this decision; do you not? COMMISSIONER DECKER: As I explained, Councilman, we did -- we will make Mr. Goppelt a user on the online system. But to open the internet up to a very wide -- just an open access, we are not positioned currently to do that. In order to do that, it will require a number of licenses, as well as a different network capacity. At this point in time we simply are not in a position to do that. All of the information, again, is -- the system is available on site for any individual that wants it. We work with members of the public. If they have difficulty coming in to City Hall our staff definitely works with them to get the information they need when they need it, whether that be via telephone, mail or fax request. We fulfill many public service requests to the citizens. The staff is very 00058 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole committed to public service. We understand what our mandate and mission is, to make public records available to the public, and we have consistently done that with great diligence.

Councilman Cohen

Madam President, in view of the answer given, I would like to put clearly in the motion that I think no 9 appropriation for the Record Department should be considered by this Council until this matter is cleared up. To be told by a public official that we have the right to put all the kinds of obstacles in the way of having the public get information, I think is a totally unsatisfactory answer. And I'm very disappointed, Commissioner Decker. But I'm going to be voting no on any effort to provide any appropriations for the Records Department until this matter is cleared up in a way that makes available to the public on the same terms as is available to the 50 private companies. And in fact, I think it ought to be much more preferential terms, to make it available 00059 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to the public free of charge, than it is to make it available to 50 private companies. I would like that there be a response during this hearing time to the question raised by Councilman Ortiz. I would like to ask that the names of the 50 groups now having access be made available today, not later. I would like to ask that this hearing be continued until some time this afternoon or tomorrow for the receipt of that information, including the law firms that get this material free of charge.

Council President Verna

At this time the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Tasco.

Councilwoman Tasco

I'd just like to ask a question. The service that this pilot program, you provide to these companies, that information is specific to them and their customers, right? COMMISSIONER DECKER: They have access -- They look up the -- They have access to all the recordings that have taken place. And they -- And they generally research the properties 00060 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole for which they are conducting business about, that's correct.

Councilwoman Tasco

So the information that they have access to on our system is not available to the general public through them. COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilwoman Tasco

All right. So, and if I want some information, I can't go in on the internet and get the same information that they have access to. I have to call your office and get that information? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Or you can come in, call our office, send in a mail request, or a fax request.

Councilwoman Tasco

Okay. So, now, what is the difficulty in providing it to the general public? In setting up the pilot program, was there any thought given to providing the information on the internet for the public? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes, it was. And as I have mentioned previously, we have two 00061 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole issues that need to be resolved in order to do that. And that is a number of licensing issues.