civus

Committee Hearing, April 2, 2003

Minutes from Philadelphia City Council Committee Hearings, Apr 2, 2003

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

Mr. King

I'd be happy to do that.

Councilman Rizzo

Would you get me one of those catalogs?

Mr. King

Sure. Maybe Madam President would like one also.

Council President Verna

I would. Why not?

Mr. King

I'll send one to everyone.

Council President Verna

That would be wonderful. Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Nutter.

Councilman Nutter

Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon, Commissioner.

Mr. King

Good afternoon.

Councilman Nutter

This may have been raised earlier, but it's a pretty quick question. What's the current census? 00125 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Nutter

And what's the generally accepted maximum capacity?

Mr. King

How do I answer that question? The capacity of the prison is those number of people that we can find adequate space for and provide safety, security and health. There really is no number that I could quote off the top of my head. And not to be disingenuous, because the way the prison system operates, you know, there are permanent housing areas that were built in the beginning of time to be housing areas. And then there are housing areas that were converted from other uses to be housing areas. And then there are other areas that we can convert if we need to.

Councilman Nutter

Commissioner?

Mr. King

Yes. Sorry.

Councilman Nutter

I think there's been litigation on this subject. And I think some determination was made at some point in time as to how many people can be in the facility. What's that number? 00126 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. King

How many beds we have in the facilities?

Councilman Nutter

Yes.

Mr. King

I'm told 7,288.

Councilman Nutter

7,280?

Mr. King

704, I think additionally for the temporary areas in C.F.C.F.

Councilman Nutter

Hold on. Slow down. 7,280 beds?

Councilman Nutter

88?

Councilman Nutter

Now, when the City was -- Wasn't there a suit about overcrowding?

Mr. King

Yes, there was.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. And in the federal litigation, why do I seem to have in my mind the number that was in the 5,000 range?

Mr. King

That was back in 1995 when the population was down, and that was the number Judge Shapiro chose as -- Well, actually it was the number the City agreed to for purposes of the litigation to try to adhere to, 5,600. 00127 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Nutter

Where did the 5,600 number come from?

Mr. King

That was a number that was negotiated with the parties in the litigation. 5,600 was what we said would be our operational goal back in 1995.

Councilman Nutter

All right.

Mr. King

And that was before Curren Fromhold was built.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. So... But now, when these buildings are built, there's usually a certificate of occupancy or something that's issued. I mean, someone has to make a decision about how many people can be in a space. So what's that number?

Mr. King

That's the number I just gave you for what we have now.

Councilman Nutter

7,288?

Councilman Nutter

Okay. So, now, are all of the inmates in cells or are some of them in places that are not considered traditional cells? Are they in other places? Are they in hallways? Are they in -- I mean... 00128 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. King

We don't house inmates in hallways, gymnasiums, or places like that. We have cells. Most of the system is cells. We have some dormitory style housing at the Detention Center. And I think that's really the two variations that we have on housing of inmates.

Councilman Nutter

So the system is not -- Based on this information, the system is under its capacity?

Mr. King

I would say so, sir, at 7,100 inmates.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. How many inmates have either a drug and/or alcohol or some other substance abuse problem?

Mr. King

I don't have an exact figure, but the statistic, I believe, is that 80 percent of the people in the prison system have some problem with alcohol or drugs.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. So that's a little over 5,000 or so? Would that be 80 percent, 5,500 something -- I mean, roughly?

Mr. King

I would guess so, yes.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. And how many... Now, while inmates are in our custody, 00129 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole are they required to take or seek any kind of drug, alcohol or substance abuse counseling?

Mr. King

It depends on what type of inmate you are. If you're a sentenced inmate, and that's part of your sentence, yes, you have to do those things. If you're a pre-trial detainee, we can't force you to do those types of things.

Councilman Nutter

How many sentenced inmates have that as part of their sentence?

Mr. King

I don't know if I could answer that off the top of my head. Do you know, Al?

Councilman Nutter

Maybe we could get -- you got a --

Mr. King

Allen's the Deputy Commissioner.

Councilman Nutter

You have a half a dozen other people here.

Mr. Appel

Approximately 600 has some requirement in their sentence.

Councilman Nutter

600. Well, what are the other 5,000 or so 00130 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole doing? I mean, why aren't they required -- I mean, you said 80 percent of the people in custody have drug, alcohol or a substance abuse problem.

Councilman Nutter

We've roughly calculated that to be somewhere in the 5,000 to 5,500 neighborhood. Now you're telling me that 600 of them have it as a part of their sentence, that they have to seek counseling. What are the other 5,000 or so doing?

Mr. King

Well, they are not seeking counseling. You have to remember about what our population is when you think about it. With 60 percent of the people being pre-trial detainees -- and I think we did a study on this maybe three weeks ago -- probably 60 percent --

Councilman Nutter

I need you to get a little closer to that microphone there.

Mr. King

60 to 70 percent of those people that are released on a weekly basis at the prison system are there a day or two or three or, you know, for two weeks. 00131 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Even if we had the resources and the space to try to get them into a program, that's not enough time to really be able to address any of their needs. It's just, you know, they're there for two weeks. And you also have to remember that when they're there, at times that we don't know, they could be bailed out, the charges could be dismissed. It's not like it's --

Councilman Nutter

What about the other 40 percent of the population? How long are they with you?

Mr. King

The average length of stay, I believe, is 75 days.

Councilman Nutter

75 days.

Mr. King

Right. But those people who are sentenced could be there, you know, for up to two years based on a single sentence. But we do try to get as many people as we can into programs like F.I.R. We have the Plato program within the prison system where some people in that program are sentenced, and some people volunteer for that program. And that's a very good program as far as addressing inmates' 00132 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole needs. We're looking to expand that when we open the Women's Detention Facility, because we find it to be a successful program. And we would really like to treat everybody who comes to the prison, because one of our main goals -- and I look at it as a legal obligation -- is to try and reduce the prison population. And the only way you're going to do that is to try to intervene to address these people's drug and alcohol problems.

Councilman Nutter

How many slots do you have?

Mr. King

Slots for what?

Councilman Nutter

Drug, alcohol or substance abuse rehabilitation?

Mr. King

In options we have 879 slots, that's the internal prison program. And I believe we have a waiting list for that. 300 or 400 inmates were waiting to get in. And you have to remember that as well, the prison system only has so much space. And for these programs to be successful, you can't mix, you know, the bad inmates who aren't in the program with the good inmates who are trying to 00133 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole improve themselves. So you have to make sure you have an isolated housing area where all the people who are participating in this therapeutic program are together and they're all there on the same with the same goals. You know, we're exploring a lot of things in this area, with limited resources, to improve those things. Because one of our obligations is to try and address those things. And it's very frustrating for us, especially with the untried population, to figure out how we're to plan for these people. If you come on a Tuesday, and you could be there three weeks, or in four days you might be gone. And we have a lot of folks in the -- a lot of groups in the community that are very interested in these issues, probably 50 or more groups that want to help. And part of the problem is organizing them and targeting them to the people that we have there long enough, that they can help.

Councilman Nutter

Do you have any 00134 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole idea why the other... And we talk about the number of inmates with the substance abuse problem, the number who have a Court-ordered requirement. Do you have any sense of why the other inmates did not have a Court-ordered requirement to get treatment?

Mr. King

I don't have a sense of that off the top of my head. It must have been -- I'm sure it has a multitude of factors: What particular judge they got --

Councilman Nutter

I need you to speak into the microphone.

Mr. King

What particular judge they had, what particular representation they had in the courtroom, what their prior record was. I understand when you're chosen for these programs, it's not just you raise your hand and say, I want to go. There are criteria; am I correct?

Mr. King

-- for to be involved in the program. And the criteria are developed to pick people who are more likely to succeed, as I understand it. So, there would be a whole 00135 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole multitude effect. We would like to see everybody who receives a sentence --

Councilman Nutter

So if an inmate decides that he or she doesn't want to participate in a program, they don't participate; is that correct?

Mr. King

Correct. I mean, if you're sentenced and you're supposed to go to the program, and you don't go, then you get some sanction, like a longer sentence.

Councilman Nutter

I understand that.

Mr. King

But if you're not sentenced and you decide, I quit, there's nothing we can do about it.

Councilman Nutter

And, so what -- I mean, let's say you have a substance abuse problem, you're in prison, you're not in a program. What happens to that person? Or in the alternative, how does the system deal with that person? I assume that it may slightly affect their behavior.

Mr. King

Well, we have -- Other than the options program, you know, we have mental 00136 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole health professionals that help because a lot of people who have drug and alcohol problems also have a mental health problem. We have social workers that try to intervene in these situations. We have a methadone program that we have started where we have a limited pool of resources. But there are some people who come in, and if they're already on methadone treatment when they come into the prison, we continue with that treatment inside the walls. But there's only so much space, so much time, and so much resources. So, if none of those sort of safety nets that we have sort of intervene, then nothing happens with you.

Councilman Nutter

What's the recidivism rate these days?

Mr. King

Our most recent statement of the recidivism rate is that 50 percent of those who are sentenced come back with -- 59 percent of those who are sentenced come back within two years with a new sentence for a new crime or as a parole violation. 00137 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Nutter

Would you parse that such that you only talked about those who are sentenced? You highlighted this other population of people. What is it, the pre-trial or...

Mr. King

Pre-trial detainees.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. Of those individuals, how many end up coming back for return visits?

Mr. King

I believe it's 80 percent; am I correct?

Mr. King

80 percent of those people come back again and again.

Councilman Nutter

You must be doing something pretty special up there.

Mr. King

I don't think that we're doing anything special, in regard to having them come back.

Councilman Nutter

They just want to come back; they just love the place.

Mr. King

They have no intervention in their lives, so they keep doing the same thing over and over and over and over again.

Councilman Nutter

Well, what are 00138 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole we doing about that?

Mr. King

There's a whole host of things that we're trying to do. One of the big things that we have going on in conjunction with the Managing Director's Office and Mayor Goode's group regarding re-entry, and all of that stuff, we're trying to organize and re-examine all of the programs that we have, and all the people that seem like they want to be involved right now, and we're trying to reorganize things to target programs to help people. But you also have to remember, with the pre-trial population, if they don't want to be helped, there's nothing that we can do about it. And we can offer all the services we want. The Mayor has come up with a discharge package that we're going to be giving, or maybe we started giving, to every inmate that has faith-based organizations they can contact, other non faith-based organizations, give them a card and tips or where they can go to get help. But once they leave the prison, no 24 matter what information that we give them, we can't force them to go and follow up. 00139 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole And while we are there, and if they're not sentenced, we can't force them -- You wouldn't want to force someone to go to a drug and alcohol treatment against their will. It wouldn't work. Because they don't want to get well. But if you have any suggestions, we're open to suggestions. We're thinking on these issues.

Councilman Nutter

How many people came into the system more than one time last year?

Mr. King

Off the top of my head, I couldn't say that. But I would say if we have an 80 percent recidivism rate, a great number of people came back over and over again.

Councilman Nutter

All right. But it's 80 percent of... You gave me 59 percent of the sentenced and 80 percent of the pre-trial detainees. What I don't know is, 59 percent of what or 80 percent of what? How many people are there as sentenced, and how many people are there as pre-trial detainees?

Councilman Nutter

I'll take today. 00140 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. King

I don't know that figure off the top of my head. Do you?

Mr. Appel

2355 sentenced.

Councilman Nutter

So 4700, 4800 in pre-trial?

Councilman Nutter

And 80 percent of those come back for one or more guest appearances?

Councilman Nutter

Is that 3,000 people?

Mr. King

That come back over and over? Yes.

Councilman Nutter

Tell me about -- I heard earlier about the G.E.D. program. And what is the level of educational training or opportunities available, and how many inmates get any kind of educational opportunity?

Mr. King

I'll let Deputy Commissioner Appel talk about the numbers. But I can tell you that we have the G.E.D. program. I can't quote you the number off the top of my head, but all of our 64 certified juvenile inmates have 00141 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to go to that program.

Councilman Nutter

Say that last part again.

Mr. King

All 64 of our certified juvenile inmates are required by law to go to the Pennypack School and, you know, work toward their G.E.D. They have to go. The rest of the folks --

Councilman Nutter

Why do they have to go?

Mr. King

State law requires that if you're under 18, you have to go to school.

Councilman Nutter

I understand that. What, if any, requirements exist for adults who don't have G.E.D. or a high school diploma?

Mr. King

I don't believe that we have any requirements that force them to go. It might be part of their sentence. But most of the other people, they're voluntary. And what we find is, because of that, the portion of our population that's untried, they may be in the middle of the G.E.D. class, they get bailed out or whatever, and they don't finish. We have a lot of people that are so 00142 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole below the literacy rate that they start, they try hard, and then they drop out. We also have the Plato Program that assists you in educational services. And I'll let Deputy Commissioner Appel talk about the numbers in more specifics.

Mr. Appel

In our last fiscal year, fiscal year '02, 2,061 inmates went through our G.E.D. program.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. Who works with the inmates on employment issues and opportunities, anticipating their release?

Mr. King

For the most part, the social worker staff work on that. And when, you know, you're in the work release program, you have a sort of continuing assistance in keeping your job, and if you lose it, getting another one.

Councilman Nutter

How many inmates coming out of the system end up in an employment opportunity?

Mr. King

I don't believe we keep statistics on that, do we?

Mr. King

No, we don't keep 00143 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole statistics on that. But we're moving on that issue, too. We have a whole group together using $2 million of the Jackson Settlement Fund. And we're re-evaluating all of that at the prison: The job opportunities that we have there, the follow-up when people are discharged, because I would like to get away from spending money on programs where, you know, to teach inmates maybe to grow flowers. When they leave, where are they going to get a job, you know, growing flowers? I don't know. So we're re-evaluating those programs. And we're going to re-allocate money in our budget so that we're not spending money, just throwing money away without being able to measure results.

Councilman Nutter

Are companies -- I mean, are some of the companies hiring people who have come out of the prison system?

Mr. King

I'm sure that there are. And Deputy Commissioner Appel can speak more on this. But we also just started a program with Aramark Corporation, who's our food service 00144 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole folks. We've developed a vocational training program with them. And they are going to be training 50 to 60 inmates over a period of time. They're going to get certificates. They've agreed to allow them to utilize their career center. Going to give them interviewing skills, and things of that nature, because that's money we're spending again. And we want to see that we are not just throwing it away. We're giving it to you. You're training the inmates. And they should be able to get some jobs when they leave. And we want to be able to see some statistics to back it up, because we're not going to continue to spend money on programs that don't evidence to the prison system that we're getting what we want out of the money. It's not just to spend money to spend money.

Councilman Nutter

Two last issues: One, what's the policy in the prisons with regard to smoking?

Mr. King

Smoking. It's a non-smoking facility... facilities.

Councilman Nutter

All the prisons 00145 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole are non-smoking?

Councilman Nutter

So the inmates cannot smoke?

Mr. King

No. Sometimes they find ways to, but they're not supposed to.

Councilman Nutter

I understand. And what are the various... I guess... I want to call it service, but I mean, I guess the things that we provide beyond food, clothing, general shelter, there are, I guess, individual -- Are there individual television video access or are there just big rooms where --

Mr. King

In most of the facilities I believe we have day rooms where there's one T.V. and they all have to go into the day room and watch the T.V. I believe we have -- we show movies in all our facilities, but we're not cable ready or cable connected. Videos come in, and our wardens and Deputy Commissioners check them for a proper content, et cetera, and, you know, they're shown to the inmates. But they don't have individual 00146 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole T.V.'s or anything like that.

Councilman Nutter

All right. Lastly, this is a topic that I know that Councilman Ortiz is particularly concerned about, so I will not venture too far into it. But there have been not so recent, but not too long ago, news accounts with regard to prison health services, services provided, various contracts, amount of contracts, and who's in or who's out. I have a concern about that particular area, but again, I know that this is an issue that Councilman Ortiz has been working on. I do want to register my concern about it. And as the questioning proceeds on that, I'll come back to that particular issue. Thank you, Commissioner.

Mr. King

Thank you.

Council President Verna

Thank you. Commissioner, before I recognize the next Council person, I'm somewhat confused with the drug treatment program, drug and alcohol. You said that 900 inmates could be treated. However, at the present time you have 00147 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole 600. How much money is appropriated for the 900 that you would be able to assist?

Mr. King

If I said 900, I meant to say 879. But it's close enough to 900.

Council President Verna

All right. So, 879. COMMISSIONER KING: And I'd ask Mr. Siemanski if he can break out the number. I think that's for the options program. Do we have that broken down?

Mr. Siemanski

Not exactly. The options program is identified on . I'd have to go through that Professional Services Responsibility Center and add up the drug counseling positions. We'd have to do that and get back to you.

Council President Verna

4514?

Mr. Siemanski

4514. Yes.

Council President Verna

And your budget detail is different from mine. This is for professional services?

Council President Verna

All right. So on -30? 00148 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. Siemanski

That's 4514. 14. Sorry. That's the professional services --

Council President Verna

I know. I have that. Distinguish between this program and the programs on -30.

Mr. Siemanski

That's the Forensic Intensive Recovery. And that's for offenders who are not in our custody.

Mr. King

And that program's run by Coda out of the Health Department.

Council President Verna

Okay. So, can you tell us for the 879 inmates how much is appropriated for drug and alcohol treatment?

Mr. Siemanski

I'd have to total them up on that 4514 and get back to you.

Council President Verna

I'd appreciate it. Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Brown.

Councilwoman Brown

Thank you, Madam. Chair. Good afternoon, gentlemen.

Mr. King

Good afternoon. 00149 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilwoman Brown

Councilman Cohen raised some questions regarding the population. And you said currently the population is at what figure?

Councilwoman Brown

Of those, how many are women?

Councilwoman Brown

And of those, how many are mothers?

Mr. King

I would have to get back to you with that number. I don't know.

Councilwoman Brown

Could you please? For this reason: I believe it was last Thursday, we had a ceremony in Council caucus, wherein we learned that P.A.N., Philadelphia Antiviolence -- Antidrug Antiviolence Network passed some programs for mothers who are incarcerated. I'm curious to know what services are sponsored by your institution, specifically for mothers who have children.

Mr. King

Okay. I will have either Deputy Commissioner Appel or Deputy Commissioner 00150 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Grooms answer that question, because we do have services for women who are pregnant. If you're pregnant in jail, we have services and assistance and with that sort of thing. I do know that Mayor Goode has been coming up to the prison on and off for the last year or two. And part of what he's doing is trying to... He interviews the inmates, finds out how many people have kids, et cetera, whether men or women. And then he tries to hook those children up with mentors, because his belief is that if you're the son or the daughter of someone who's in prison, there's a very high likelihood that you'll end up the same way if someone doesn't intervene. So, we have that. And I'll let --

Councilwoman Brown

Really, I should not discriminate. I should just say parents, because men or women. Their children matter.

Mr. King

I'll let Deputy Commissioner Appel talk on that in a little more detail.

Councilman Cohen

I have both 00151 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole hearing aids on. I've re-checked them a number of times. I've never had this difficulty in hearing.

Mr. King

I'll make a greater effort to talk into the microphone so that you can hear me.

Councilman Cohen

Please do, because otherwise you're just wasting your time because you're going to get a repetitious number of questions. Most Council Members are more polite than I am and will raise the question once or twice, and then just give up.

Councilman Cohen

Thank you.

Councilwoman Brown

Good afternoon.

Mr. Appel

We have a number of programs that address the parenting. We have the Parent Action Network, which is a program sponsored by DHS --

Councilwoman Brown

Okay.

Mr. Appel

-- that provides groups to both the men and the women.

Councilwoman Brown

Okay.

Mr. Appel

We have a parenting 00152 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole skills program provided by the Salvation Army. We also have parenting skills built in to the Options Drug Treatment Program.

Councilwoman Brown

Are these programs occupational or mandatory?

Mr. Appel

They're all occupational.

Councilwoman Brown

And so given that, what's the participation rate?

Mr. Appel

We can fill every spot that we have. These are very --

Councilwoman Brown

Popular?

Mr. Appel

Yes. Popular among the --

Councilwoman Brown

So there is actually more interest than there is room?

Mr. Appel

Yes. Yes.

Councilwoman Brown

Okay.

Mr. Appel

We would certainly like to increase that number, but that's what we have right now.

Councilwoman Brown

It's all tied to funding from D.H.S.?

Mr. Appel

Yes, it is. Yes, it is. 00153 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilwoman Brown

Okay. The other number I'd be curious to know: Of those parents, are those children with a designated blood parent or are they in foster care? So as you bring the numbers back to Madam President, if you could break that out. There are 818 women, under "X" number of women who are mothers, there are "X" number of men who are fathers. Of those "X" number of children are in D.H.S. Of that number, how many are in foster care?

Councilwoman Brown

Okay? Thank you, gentlemen.

Councilwoman Brown

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Council President Verna

The Chair recognizes Councilman Ortiz.

Councilman Ortiz

Thank you, Madam Chair. Commissioner.

Mr. King

Good afternoon.

Councilman Ortiz

It's still Commissioner or Acting Commissioner? 00154 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. King

Still acting.

Councilman Ortiz

Okay. You've been acting now for how long?

Mr. King

Since December 19th.

Councilman Ortiz

Commissioner, you said you have 600 inmates that currently have a requirement as part of their sentencing for drug treatment?

Mr. King

I think that was the number.

Councilman Ortiz

But you have 179 slots overall?