civus

Committee Hearing, April 2, 2003

Minutes from Philadelphia City Council Committee Hearings, Apr 2, 2003

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

Councilman Ortiz

879. And you've told Councilman Nutter that at least 80-something percent of the inmates have a drug problem, they don't get no treatment at all.

Mr. King

It's not that they don't get any treatment at all. Some of them --

Councilman Ortiz

They go into the DTs, and so on. And what happens?

Mr. King

Some of them get 00155 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole treatment. If you come into the Philadelphia prison system and you're going through withdrawals, you are taken care of by the medical folks. Some people go to methodone, detox and treatment. We only have a certain amount of room. Other people are treated with various medications.

Councilman Ortiz

You have a medical program there, right, on site?

Mr. King

Yes, we do.

Councilman Ortiz

Speak to the microphone.

Mr. King

Yes, we do.

Councilman Ortiz

Councilman Cohen can't hear you.

Mr. King

Yes, we do. We have a medical operation on site.

Councilman Ortiz

What's the amount of the monies that we paid out to this company?

Mr. King

Approximately $42 million.

Councilman Ortiz

$42 million. That's up from in the last contract, right? 24

Mr. King

No. I don't think it 25 was. It's up from -- The last contract go around 00156 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole was 30... 38?

Councilman Ortiz

Well, no; that was with the addition.

Councilman Ortiz

That was with the addition.

Councilman Ortiz

That was with the addition. It was 28... $26, $28 million, and then we added an extension to it. So it brought it up to something like 36, or something like that.

Councilman Ortiz

We have not signed a contract yet with this company, right? Are we putting this contract up for bid?

Mr. King

That decision has not been made yet.

Councilman Ortiz

So they're still sort of like acting, just like you.

Mr. King

Well, no. You know, from my point of view, acting is not a word I keep in my head.

Councilman Ortiz

Well, they have a 00157 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole contract now, and that contract extends to where, to what time?

Mr. King

June 30th.

Councilman Ortiz

Go ahead, Councilman Nutter.

Councilman Nutter

Thank you, Councilman Ortiz. Commissioner, reading from 4530, line item 250, you have, prison health services in fiscal 2002 at $26.2 million, current fiscal year, $35 million, and the next fiscal year, $42.6 million. I believe that's a more than 50 percent increase over 2002?

Mr. King

Let me look. It's a little less than 50 percent.

Councilman Nutter

No. I'm talking about 2002 compared to 2004. You have a $16 million increase from fiscal '02 to fiscal '04, correct? I think $16 million is a little more than 50 percent of $26 million?

Councilman Nutter

Okay. So, in two fiscal years we've had a more than 50 percent increase, correct? 00158 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. King

Looks like it, yes.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. All right. Councilman, thank you.

Councilman Ortiz

And that's without -- That increase has been done without actually going to a bid process, right?

Mr. King

That's been done without going through a complete bid.

Councilman Ortiz

A bid process?

Mr. King

Complete bid process, yes.

Councilman Ortiz

Well, no; you can't be half pregnant. I mean, you either go to a bid process or you go through no bid process.

Councilman Ortiz

And so, that increase has gone up without a bid process in place. And with all of the record that we have about this company. And have they fully staffed their people there? Do they staff now? Do they have a full staff of nurses, doctors, and so on?

Mr. King

The staffing pattern at 00159 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole the prison has been evolving, but it's not evolving where I would like it nor the rest of the prison staff.

Councilman Ortiz

The answer is no. 6

Mr. King

They need more people.

Councilman Cohen

Can I ask you speak into the microphone.

Mr. King

We need more people. And if we do not have --

Councilman Cohen

Or we'll have to write all these questions and ask them again.

Mr. King

We don't have all the people that we're required to have.

Councilman Ortiz

When you tell me they're evolving...

Councilman Ortiz

...they've been evolving since 1992 when they got the contract, right?

Councilman Ortiz

That means that they don't have a full staff. The answer is no. 24

Mr. King

Correct, they do not.

Councilman Ortiz

Okay. And we 00160 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole haven't had one --

Mr. King

We're working on that, though, Councilman.

Councilman Ortiz

Yes indeed. I mean, We've been working on this with this company since 1992.

Mr. King

Well, we're working it a little differently this time.

Councilman Ortiz

Well, yeah. Yes indeed. You know, we got to be working hard to make them --

Councilman Ortiz

-- earn their $42 million.

Mr. King

We've told them that.

Councilman Ortiz

We're going to do that. Now, for that $42 million, you mean they can't handle more than 879 individuals in terms of drug treatment, and so on?

Mr. King

They don't do the drug treatment.

Councilman Ortiz

They don't do the drug treatment. 00161 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Ortiz

So if a guy goes into overdose, what happens? Because they do get drugs there; you know that, right?

Mr. King

Sometimes inmates smuggle drugs into the prison, yes.

Councilman Ortiz

You know they get drugs in the prison, right?

Mr. King

Sometimes, yes.

Councilman Ortiz

Yes. So a guy goes into a drug overdose or he goes into the D.T.s, what happens; who treats him?

Mr. King

Medical staff.

Councilman Ortiz

Do they treat him?

Councilman Ortiz

They treat him?

Councilman Ortiz

But as far as like an options program or the other things we've been talking about, medical -- P.H.S. doesn't handle those things.

Councilman Ortiz

No. Who handles that? 00162 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. King

F.I.R.s, Codap. The options is a prison operation.

Councilman Ortiz

Do they come in? Are they in-house?

Mr. King

Options, yes. Those are all social workers from the Deputy Commissioner --

Councilman Ortiz

Codap is in-house?

Mr. King

Codap is the Health Department.

Councilman Ortiz

Okay.

Mr. King

Those inmates are taken out of the prison system, and they're being treated on the street, not in the prison system.

Councilman Ortiz

Oh, they're taken out for their treatment, and they're brought back in?

Mr. King

No. No, no. You're in jail. You go -- you're sentenced. F.I.R. is made part of your sentence, so instead of staying in the prison, they take you out, put you in a home --

Council President Verna

Would they be considered early parolees? 00163 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. King

I believe so, yes.

Councilman Ortiz

So they're not in the prison?

Councilman Ortiz

So these individuals, really, are not being treated in the prison. These individuals are outside. They are in halfway houses or whatever it is?

Mr. King

The F.I.R. people. The options people are being treated in the prison by prison staff.

Councilman Ortiz

How many people is that?

Mr. King

In the options?

Councilman Ortiz

Yeah.

Councilman Ortiz

But they don't get treated by P.H.S.

Mr. King

No, unless they have a medical problem or something.

Councilman Ortiz

I mean, drug is a medical problem, isn't it?

Mr. King

I mean, their counseling and the things that they go through, and their 00164 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole housing area, it's all prison staff, not the prison health services.

Councilman Ortiz

Okay. So tell me: What do they do right now and what do they do for that $42 million? And it's going on until June 30th, right?

Councilman Ortiz

What services do they provide?

Mr. King

Excuse me a minute. Miss Steiker corrects me, and says this fiscal year the amount is closer to $37 million. But to answer your question --

Councilman Ortiz

What's a few million among friends.

Mr. King

I understand the point. Generally speaking, they provide medical services and behavioral health services to the inmates within the Philadelphia prison system. That's their general charge. That's their general job. And what we're trying to get them to do is do it a little bit better than they have been doing it in the past.

Councilman Ortiz

And what are we 00165 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole doing to make them do it a little bit better? In their contract, do they suffer any penalties if they don't fulfill the requirements of the contract?

Mr. King

Actually, there are liquidated damages provided for in this contract. I believe there always have been. We just haven't -- We haven't used them, as far as I know.

Councilman Ortiz

Well, you never used them.

Mr. King

That's as far as I know, we've never used them.

Councilman Ortiz

Councilman says you have a copy of the contract.

Mr. King

Sure. I don't have one with me, but I could get you a copy if you would like.

Councilman Ortiz

Please do that.

Councilman Cohen

Do you have it during the hearings? We don't want the contract after the hearings are over. And I'm going to request again that this budget be held up, any action by Council, until we get a copy of the medical contract, and 00166 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole an opportunity for Council to study it.

Councilman Ortiz

Of the latest extension.

Councilman Cohen

If you can get it brought in today, it would be very helpful.

Mr. King

We have it here, if you would like.

Councilman Ortiz

Is that the latest extension?

Councilman Cohen

Could we get it?

Mr. King

Yes. (Handed to Sergeant-at-arms)

Councilman Ortiz

In terms of behavioral programs, how are they set up? How many people do they have; and how many people do they see, of the inmates?

Mr. King

I don't have those numbers off the top of my head. But I -- Deputy Commission Grooms, can you comment on that?

Mr. Grooms

Press Grooms, Deputy Commissioner. At the last totaling, there were approximately 1500 inmates on the behavioral health medication program.

Councilman Ortiz

1500. 00167 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Ortiz

What is the process? Joe Jones has problem. What does he do? He's in his cell. What happens?

Mr. Grooms

If Joe Jones is in his cell and is having some behavior health problems, is that your question?

Councilman Ortiz

Well, what happens? He needs some help. What happens with him? I mean, he obviously needs some help. What does the prison do? And what are the services provided to him, except to drug him, other than to drug him?

Mr. Grooms

Well, the prison system medical services is provided to inmates. They provide dental services. They provide --

Councilman Ortiz

I'm talking about the behavioral. What happens? I mean, you said medication. That to me is that Joe Jones, acting up, he goes and they give him some drugs, some aspect in order to just, you know, dope him out and keep him quiet. If there is a behavioral problem with Joe Jones, what is the treatment that he gets? 00168 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. Grooms

Okay. Let me say something to you: There's a difference between medication and treatment. If Joe Jones has been identified as a behavioral health person who has a mental health problem, he or she will receive counseling by certified counselors. They receive therapy from time to time, and they receive a group therapy on a regular basis by the therapists that are employed by P.H.S. That's what happens to that individual.

Councilman Ortiz

That's what I want to know. That is the answer. And how many times -- how many times a week does this happen? How many times a day or how many times a week does this take place?

Mr. Grooms

Therapy is ongoing on a daily basis. The therapists are there approximately 16 hours a day, and therapy goes on on a daily basis. Sometime that therapy is provided by P.H.S. Sometime that therapy is provided by our social service department. And as that service is provided, it is recorded on a regular basis by 00169 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole individuals who are certified to do it. Once it's recorded, then we, the prison system, audits that service. That service is sometimes audited by Dr. Gratfinger, or Dr. Patterson. And we have auditors there that -- on a regular basis -- on a scheduled basis, who comes in and audits the records to ensure that those inmates are being serviced, and that they are receiving the proper treatment.

Councilman Ortiz

Joe Jones is arrested, right? And he's taken from the Roundhouse to your establishment. What happens?

Mr. Grooms

I'm assuming you're talking about somebody that has a mental health problem.

Councilman Ortiz

I'm assuming Joe Jones, whatever. He's arrested. He's taken from the Roundhouse. He's going to be incarcerated because he cannot make bail. He's too poor.

Councilman Ortiz

And what happens when he gets to your establishment? What happens to him?

Mr. Grooms

Let me explain to you 00170 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole what happens to him prior to him leaving the Roundhouse.

Councilman Ortiz

Tell me what happens.

Mr. Grooms

If that person has an ailment -- and of course none of our inmates have ailments -- that ailment is identified at the Roundhouse. Prior to that person coming to the prison system, the information is faxed to the medical department at the prison system. Once that person's arrived at the prison, the medical department or the nurse has that file or that fax. Immediately that person is pulled out of the group of individuals of other inmates and taken to medical services. Not only that, but those inmates that may not identify at the P.A.B., when they arrived, we have officers that --

Councilman Ortiz

Translate P.A.B.

Mr. Grooms

P.A.B. Police Administration Building.

Councilman Ortiz

Okay.

Mr. Grooms

The officer... Once 00171 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole the inmate arrives, the officer will query that inmate, ask him, is there anyone in this group has a medical problem. Secondly, we have signs posted. We have signs posted in the intake area in English and Spanish for inmates to read. Thirdly, the nurse will also come out and ask, is there anyone here that has a medical problem. We are very concerned about those inmates that come in with illnesses, and we're making it a point to ensure that those inmates receive the necessary services in order to provide them with the health care that they require.

Councilman Ortiz

So he identifies himself. You don't do a medical examination of the individual?

Mr. Grooms

He not only -- He or she not only identifies themselves; the medical department will identify individuals also, and the corrections officers. So there's several ways that a person can be identified as having a medical problem.

Councilman Ortiz

If he says he's 00172 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole drug addicted, what happens?

Mr. Grooms

If he says he's drug addicted? He's put ahead of the line. He's taken immediately to be seen by someone from medical. And that we have a medical screen, and we question -- which has about -- I'm going -- it's about -- roughly about 50 questions. And we ask the necessary questions, based on that medical screening. And if that person has a drug problem, he or she will be administered to.

Councilman Ortiz

If he has H.I.V., what happens?

Mr. Grooms

Same thing applies. First of all, that person, if he self admits, then he will be given the necessary medication, once it's been verified by the medical personnel that he has H.I.V.

Councilman Ortiz

How many people right now in prison are identifiable with H.I.V.?

Mr. King

I don't have that number off the top of my head, but I can give it to you.

Councilman Ortiz

Or Hepatitis C?

Mr. King

I don't have that number either, and that's also -- 00173 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Ortiz

But you do have a number for those?

Mr. King

I can get a number for H.I.V., I believe, and Hepatitis C, I think so, too, yes.

Councilman Ortiz

And there is treatment that is given to these individuals at the prison by P.H.S.?

Councilman Ortiz

In terms of H.I.V., and Hepatitis, and so on?

Councilman Ortiz

And they're seen daily?

Mr. King

They're seen -- If medically necessary for them to be seen daily, they're seen daily.

Councilman Ortiz

Okay.

Councilman Ortiz

Could you give us what the staffing levels of P.H.S. are?

Mr. King

I can't give you the staffing levels of P.H.S. There are another thing we're working on. We have a completely new 00174 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole staffing plan. And one of the problems we had always had, they can't --

Councilman Ortiz

You've got to speak into the microphone.

Mr. King

One of the problems we've always had is, historically at the prisons you can't find nurses. You just can't find them. It's an international problem, as I've recently read in one of the correctional journals. You just can't find nurses. Even teaching universities and things of that nature can't find enough nurses. And when you think about it, based on, you know, the prison environment, nurses don't want to work in the prison. So we've been trying to tackle that problem for years. And I think now we've finally got a handle on a plan that doesn't rely so much on nurses.

Councilman Ortiz

Well, I'd like to see what the staffing plan is that P.H.S. proposes for the population that we have.

Councilman Ortiz

What is the 00175 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole staffing plan that they have, and what is the actual staffing that they have? In terms of a relationship with doctors to patients, nurses to patient, social workers to patient, and so on down the line. Can you make that available to the Chair?

Councilman Ortiz

Okay? And can you make it available soon?

Councilman Ortiz

Okay. Thank you.

Council President Verna

You're welcome. The Chair recognizes Councilman Mariano.

Councilman Mariano

Thank you, Madam President. Aren't you glad you went to law school for all this, Commissioner? Up in the part of my District between Whittaker Avenue and Erie Avenue and G Street, the state has several privately run -- Well, the state doesn't. There's several privately run work release facilities. 00176 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Mariano

But mostly state prisoners go there. They're work release facilities. People want to call them halfway houses, but they technically call them -- City have any of them?

Mr. King

Yes. We have one work release facility at 600 University Avenue in West Philadelphia.

Councilman Mariano

Would we be looking to have any more of them?

Mr. King

It would depend on the -- We would always love to expand the work release program.

Councilman Mariano

Does the program -- Can you speak a little about that program? It seems to work well with the state prisoners. I don't know about the county prisoners. I guess it's the same.

Mr. King

Well, I am sure the programs are similar, and I could have a Deputy Commission Appel speak more specifically about that. But the way it's set up right now, 00177 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole the Judges in the Court of Common Pleas decide who is eligible to be on work release. They then come to us. We have to investigate and verify whether they told the judge the truth about the circumstances in which they work. Well, then, we put them out to work. And we have a whole staff down at the work release center that's dedicated to making sure they go where they're supposed to go, and come back. If you're sentenced to work release and you don't have a job, we have people there to go out and help you find a job. If you lose your job, we help you find a job. The prison has always taken the position that we would like to be the ones to decide who goes on work release, as opposed to the judges. We could identify people that may be more appropriate, because we also have a problem with people walking away from the work release programs. So, someone stipulated to work release, that's maybe someone the prison wouldn't have on work release, but we're forced to take 00178 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole that person, and then they walk away because they weren't qualified in the beginning to be in the program.

Councilman Mariano

I visited all three, but the one that strikes me the most is named after a former Council President here, Joseph Coleman Center. And it's an outfit from New Jersey whose name escapes me that runs it. One of the things when I did a tour of it, and I went back for a follow-up tour, one of the things that struck me is, some of the people that get in there realize that they might not want to be in there because they're constantly in motion. There's no down time. There's no 16 waiting room. There's no place to stay in your cell. If you're not going through intensive classes, you're out either working or looking for a job. And as far as I can see, a lot of trepidation from the neighborhood, because they don't really understand it. But their thinking behind it in the first place was to put it in the neighborhoods where the people come from. And it seems to be working. 00179 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole And you see at certain times the populations moving, you know, getting on the trolley, getting on the el. And it seems to work. And knock on wood nothing happens there, because it's one of them situations where the littlest thing that happens, they want to blame it on them. But if you could have the Deputy Commissioner speak of how it works at the one the City has.

Mr. King

All right. Deputy Commissioner Appel. I just want to comment just one thing on that that people need to think about. We're all very focused on re-entry and recidivism, and all of that. And a lot of times people are opposed to these sorts of places being in their neighborhoods. But what they have to remember is, if we don't intercede in these people's lives and try to change their behavior, when they leave, instead of going to the halfway house, they just go back down the street where they were into a house that doesn't have a sign over it, and they cause a lot of trouble. 00180 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Mariano

You sound like me, Commissioner. I tell this at this one City group all the time. And, you know, I try to look people in the eye and say, you know what? These are our sons and our fathers and our uncles. And I think one of them has -- the Luzerne Treatment Facility has a female population.

Councilman Mariano

So I mean, I'm not ashamed to say it. I know two people that have been in both of those work release facilities, and it worked out. So, maybe to speak to what Councilman Nutter said about the recidivism, this might be not the total answer, but it may be something. I mean, obviously the people that can't be in them, you're going to have your problems.

Councilman Mariano

But the one at the Coleman Center is run by some very serious individuals. And most of the counselors there are former inmates themselves, maybe 10, 15, 20 years 00181 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole ago. But nobody's fooling them on anything. I was really impressed. But I get that every month at the Civic Association. Everything that goes wrong, somebody's walking by looking in their windows; and it's like, no 7 they're not because they're not on that street. But it becomes a political football, but we deal with that. And what we did here in Council is, we had a bill a couple years ago where they have to go through Zoning, no matter where they are, so it seems to work out.

Mr. King

I'll let Deputy Commissioner Appel talk on that.

Mr. Appel

Hello, Councilman. Unlike the state work release program, in the one that we operate we do not select the inmates that are placed on the program. They are selected and placed by their sentencing judge.

Councilman Mariano

At the time of sentencing?

Mr. Appel

Well, they are mostly when they are sentenced. But some have their lawyers file while they're with us. But within that parameter -- and it 00182 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole is one that we would like to see reviewed -- 593 inmates were in the work release program during the fiscal year '02, with an average population of 197.

Councilman Mariano

Commissioner, not to interrupt you.

Councilman Mariano

Do you have any numbers of maybe '01 or '00 with the recidivism rate? What I'm getting at is, the recidivism, is it lower when they go to work release or is it the same or higher?