civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 2, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 2, 20267h 50m

thank you chair uh please promote nilda pimentel to the uh panel

Similar wording

they're being promoted okay and then you're okay with this right council yes all right

Similar wording

can you all hear me good afternoon I Nilda yes please could you please your name and spell for

Similar wording

the stenographer yes n-i-l-d-a pimentel p-i-m-e-n-t-e-l right do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth yes i do please proceed yes good afternoon

Similar wording

mr chairman and members of the zoning board uh i'm participating uh representing nascan the

Similar wording

coordinating rco as it's our practice we uh consult with the neighbors of the proposed

Similar wording

uh project on the west and east sides of the property on fair hill and reese streets

Similar wording

uh where many of the homes will be located um out of a total of 14 neighbors that were contacted

Similar wording

12 of them are homeowners and we can report that we did not receive any negative feedback from them

Similar wording

nor any indicated any opposition to the project as we indicated in the explanation letter that

Similar wording

we submitted. Our art CEO is satisfied with the materials.

Similar wording

Our CEO is satisfied with the materials combination of the composite wood, the brick veneer, the developers are proposing to use in the construction.

Similar wording

We're also very pleased with the landscaping plan and we have no issues whatsoever with the height, the dimensional requests that have been made.

Similar wording

Our opinion is that the proposed homes are going to enhance the surrounding aesthetically.

Similar wording

The homes not only be great for the individuals that will occupy, but also for the neighbors to have those type of homes on their block,

Similar wording

particularly when you have some packets in those two blocks that are a little unkept.

Similar wording

So the benefits for the current homeowners, as well as the nearby neighbors, we believe will outweigh any adverse effects from approving the variances.

Similar wording

So we're pleased, as we indicated in the letter, that the developers have agreed to work with the RCO in helping to identify some potential homeowners and also recommend different types of trees to be planted around the development.

Similar wording

In conclusion, consistent with the vote that was taken at the Sony meeting, our CEO fully supports this application, and we hope that you see it also.

Similar wording

So, Mr. Chairman, hopefully you'll support the application.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you very much for getting on.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

See you, everybody, at 2 p.m.

Similar wording

okay so we want to we have one case we want to finish up from this morning and it's um

Similar wording

um 521 susquehanna avenue darwin is there anything else you need to add

Similar wording

no no um uh i take that back i literally just got an email from the rco saying that they received

Similar wording

a letter of non-opposition from the council person's office okay so i don't know you can

Similar wording

once you get that could you

Similar wording

from that case here why don't we do this why don't we wait because i i still he we still

Similar wording

got to finish up then we're going to go to the board okay all right so thank you we'll we'll

Similar wording

make sure we get a copy of that all right yeah questions from the board yes i have a question

Similar wording

can you pull up the site plan again um shows the parking

Similar wording

and then for this have you done a preliminary streets review for the curb cuts for the front

Similar wording

loaded parking spaces i would defer to the architect on that but just in the general

Similar wording

general process you know streets the streets department checklist has to be submitted before

Similar wording

before an application is submitted under the Eclipse program.

Similar wording

Well aware.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

So if you don't mind, I'll take it.

Similar wording

Barley here again.

Similar wording

Yes, we have submitted to Street.

Similar wording

We had a few good comments with respect to the curb cuts and the overall design.

Similar wording

We revised and got approved for prerequisite zoning submission.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay. And then what is the, what is your plan for the stormwater management?

Similar wording

What we did, I believe that what we did is basically we have enough open space to accommodate for the stormwater.

Similar wording

It's going to be single families separated.

Similar wording

So they're not considering this entire site is above the 5,000 square feet?

Similar wording

i i believe they don't let me make sure that i'm giving you the correct information okay

Similar wording

yeah i mean i know the regulation changed this year but i thought this was still in its

Similar wording

yeah and and i understand your concern however what we are doing yes we're reconfiguring the

Similar wording

lots so we're making these four well two smaller lots with two bigger lots into ten lots all the

Similar wording

lots are i understand but the pwd generally considers that a same project so it's still

Similar wording

it's and requires the criteria um which is why i was i'm asking because i think a lot of those

Similar wording

aspects of the project have a lot of ways that they kind of integrate into

Similar wording

all the pieces that we're talking about for zoning so if we're talking about the

Similar wording

all the pieces that we're talking about for zoning so if we're talking about the roof deck

Similar wording

roof deck we're talking about

Similar wording

we're talking about the sight lines we're talking about walkways and drainage and water and grass

Similar wording

it's all of the things that are on this plan now and um it would be the first development

Similar wording

of that scale in this specific surrounding area while there are lots of other housing developments

Similar wording

they all predate these regulations and so i just want to know because some of that's not currently

Similar wording

shown in this plan and is going to alter where things end up being and so yeah so when I'm

Similar wording

looking at the records I do see that our civil engineers submitted for a utility plan a grading

Similar wording

plan and a landscape plan but I don't see the requirement for the stormwater okay so right now

Similar wording

these green roofs aren't planted green roofs these are roof decks these are roof decks yes okay

Similar wording

Okay. And then is there a specific reason that Lot J is being left vacant? Like, is there a use for Lot J? Or is that just like future development potential?

Similar wording

It's future development. We're thinking that we can make it into a corner store, but we're...

Similar wording

But it's not on the corner.

Similar wording

Lot J is two lots in from the corner.

Similar wording

The corner is 517, and that's essentially where 521 was.

Similar wording

Yes, you're right.

Similar wording

And I think that's what confused me earlier.

Similar wording

I think you cleared up some of the questions, but that's an outstanding question.

Similar wording

Nonetheless, commercial is being content-filled.

Similar wording

Commercial, okay.

Similar wording

That's our intention.

Similar wording

okay all the questions yes okay let me make sure i understand each one of these units is going to

Similar wording

have its own uh parking pad if you will and each one is going to have its own deck

Similar wording

roof deck roof deck okay all right um thank you okay so on this plan when when i'm seeing these

Similar wording

cars why are they on here it is that i don't see that it's showing like turning radius like you

Similar wording

would usually see if we're talking about a parking. That's absolutely correct. So the plan

Similar wording

that you're looking at is really, I simplified it for presentation purposes, but we do have the

Similar wording

street department with the turning radiuses showing that each and every parking spot is

Similar wording

basically within the turning radiuses. I could, if you'd like to see it, I do have it on my screen.

Similar wording

I could I could share it and show it to you one might take a second to come up let me know if you

Similar wording

see it yep yeah so um so here you would see the labels of each parking and kind of showing

Similar wording

how does uh add egress and uh egress of a car coming in with the radiuses so squad is at the

Similar wording

bottom and ferry is at the top all right okay thank you all the questions what what's the square

Similar wording

footage of of the units generally um they are about 1800 to 2000 square feet okay

Similar wording

decent decent sized units and they're all for sale see fee simple right that's correct

Similar wording

questions mind you we had a we had permits back in 2021 to build 33 rental units and now

Similar wording

we're doing home ownership that that's a good thing

Similar wording

none at this time comments from the virtual audience come on up

Similar wording

could you please state your name and spell it for the stenographer

Similar wording

good afternoon um snow folks office of council member catchy lazada slo a n e f s and fire

Similar wording

or lks do you swear or affirm to tell the truth told truth nothing but the truth slow yes i do

Similar wording

thank you chairman bergman and board um i'm just here to clear up the issue of a letter

Similar wording

of support slash non-opposition to this project speak up just a little i'm sorry yeah you go is

Similar wording

that better yeah that's wonderful yes we uh whatever reason um we had one of our staff

Similar wording

one of our staff send a letter of non-opposition that the board obviously didn't receive

Similar wording

send a letter of non-opposition that the board obviously didn't receive but i'm here

Similar wording

but i'm here to state that the council member uh has no no opposition uh and supports this project

Similar wording

fully thank you thank you very much for coming and we appreciate it anyone else in the virtual

Similar wording

audience good afternoon this is doreen i will be co-host in the afternoon sessions and there

Similar wording

are no hands planning commission good afternoon liz fuselay on behalf of this philadelphia city

Similar wording

planning commission in a community requested map change in what is now the existing zoning

Similar wording

521 to 523 susquehanna are zoned rm1 residential multi-family 527 susquehanna is cmx1

Similar wording

neighborhood commercial mixed use and 2209 fairhill is zoned rsa5 residential single family

Similar wording

these locations are within a predominantly single family row home neighborhood with on street

Similar wording

parking. With the parcel line realignment, the applicant proposes to develop 9 of the

Similar wording

10 available lots. If the 10th parcel were included, the min requirement for affordable

Similar wording

units would be activated. The lot size change is de minimis and in line with existing development

Similar wording

in the neighborhood. But for a 14 duplex residential development, the majority of existing row

Similar wording

homes do not include off-street parking. Adding off-street parking will increase the number

Similar wording

of curb cuts and decrease the readily available off-street parking for the community there are

Similar wording

no unique physical conditions or circumstances of this property that would prevent it from being

Similar wording

used in strict conformity with the zoning code the city planning commission recommends that

Similar wording

the board deny the use variances for front yard setbacks and off-street parking and grant the

Similar wording

variance for minimum lot size as it is de minimis thank you MI 2026 002 189 521 West Susquehanna Avenue

Similar wording

I vote yes Michael Johns my vote is yes Cheryl Gaston my vote is yes Tanetta Graham my vote is

Similar wording

yes Ryan McAdams my vote is yes Ty Owen my vote is yes Layla Beebe my vote is yes

Similar wording

is there anyone thank you uh darwin thank you so much for everyone thank you appreciate it right

Similar wording

uh is there anyone in the audience whose case hasn't been called from this morning just to

Similar wording

double check i do have a hand up from daniel daniel oh it went down oh here he is daniel connor

Similar wording

mr connor's case is on the 2 p.m list we'll be calling it shortly

Similar wording

okay thank you thank you okay so we're going to go to the the two o'clock list good afternoon

Similar wording

everyone my name is bill bergman i will be chairing the zba meeting this afternoon with me

Similar wording

is our vice chair tenetta graham president mr chairman board secretary cheryl l gaston

Similar wording

president mr chairman member michael johns president mr chairman iowen president mr

Similar wording

chairman i mcadams president mr chairman bb president mr chairman also here is our attorney

Similar wording

lynn reuter uber our executive director ian haggard and our board administrator lakisha dandy

Similar wording

the hearing is being recorded and will be posted on the zba website by posting um

Similar wording

by by participating you consent to be recorded this is an in-person meeting with remote

Similar wording

participation whether in person or on zoom if you're called to speak please state and spell

Similar wording

your name wait to be sworn in and then after that each time you testify start by stating your name

Similar wording

to enter an appearance indicate the property address on the zoom webinar speak with the staff

Similar wording

member call the zba office by the close of business tomorrow at 215-686-2429 and provide

Similar wording

your name email and the address of the property in question remote participation

Similar wording

raise your virtual hand when directed so that we can call you to speak when we do

Similar wording

call you click the join as a panelist button use the Q&A only for procedural

Similar wording

questions nothing to do with the cases if you are joining by phone press star

Similar wording

nine to raise your hand at the star six to unmute in person attendees if testifying get close to

Similar wording

the microphone so that all attendees and the court reporter can hear you from talking eating or

Similar wording

drinking during the hearings aggressive behavior will not be tolerated in a emergency if we have

Similar wording

to have in an emergency please follow the instructions that the staff give you the main

Similar wording

exit is the double doors at the rear and the nearest stairwell is to the left once you get

Similar wording

outside in the event that we do evacuate please go to love park and remain right across the street

Similar wording

you're on archery so that we can account for you so is there anyone who needs a a continuance for

Similar wording

So, is there anyone who needs a continuance for the 2 p.m. list?

Similar wording

the

Similar wording

There are no hands on the virtual audience.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you. So, we're going to go to our add-on list. So, MI2025 001 676 601 Devereux Avenue.

Similar wording

the vote for this has been moved to 9 16 26 at 2 p.m number two mi 20 26 002 241 101 59 rury road

Similar wording

the vote for that has been moved to um i'm sorry this is a temper i vote temporary variance

Similar wording

expires 9-3-29 and the proviso hold on my new list here

Similar wording

this one here

Similar wording

religious assembly on first floor and with single single family household living above

Similar wording

and also temporary variance to expire on 9-3-23.

Similar wording

Twenty-nine.

Similar wording

Frank Lloyd-Johns, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Kaya Nguyen, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

number three mi 20 23 006 733 1108 hawthorne street i vote yes and proviso here right

Similar wording

spanish interpreter when his spanish interpreter come for this one we need yes we need a spanish

Similar wording

spanish interpreter

Similar wording

the spanish interpreter can you raise your hand virtual hand

Similar wording

promoting them now

Similar wording

Hi, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Name is Consuelo Villagomez, C-O-N-S-U-E-L-O, via St. Victor, I-L-L-A-G-O-M-E-Z.

Similar wording

and we will swear you in mm-hmm sorry good afternoon do you swear or firm to uh accurately

Similar wording

translate from english to spanish and spanish to english yes i do thank you

Similar wording

okay so uh we're going to do the vote on um 1108 hawthorne street it's joseph vaquero was the

Similar wording

attorney um and my vote is yes

Similar wording

michael jones my vote is yes michael jones potakee

Similar wording

sherry gaston my vote is no sherry gaston but i know it's not a gram my vote is yes

Similar wording

Jonathan Graham, mi voto es sí.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, mi voto es sí.

Similar wording

Tywin, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Tywin, mi voto es sí.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Gracias.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And number four, MI-2025-005-061-3033 North 15th Street.

Similar wording

I vote no to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is no to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is no to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is no to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Layla Beebe, my vote is no to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Okay, we're going to go to our regular list here.

Similar wording

Start with number 12.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Number 12, MI 2026, 003-493-5325 Kershaw Street.

Similar wording

Vern Anastasio is the attorney.

Similar wording