civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 2, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 2, 20267h 50m

I can go to parcel section 10.

Similar wording

We'll start with nine.

Similar wording

Here is the survey.

Similar wording

we're looking at four parcels, four existing parcels, one large one, another large one at the

Similar wording

corner, and two small ones. That will be subdivided and we will create 10 parcels A, B, C, D, all the

Similar wording

way through parcel J. As I mentioned before, parcel J is not part of this application because

Similar wording

frankly we're going to look to um possibly make that into commercial again as i mentioned this

Similar wording

is an application for nine single family homes um is is the architect available

Similar wording

architect please hey board architects here my name is bar levy um you're the architect sure

Similar wording

uh yeah i'm i'm an architect but i think you know she's on the record yeah who okay darwin

Similar wording

who are they the architect they are the architects i believe the okay who's going to testify

Similar wording

i'll take it yeah i will testify okay all right could you please state your name and spell for

Similar wording

the stenographer uh it's bar levy b-a-r-l-e-v-y right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

the whole truth nothing but the truth i do counsel okay i'm just gonna ask bar to walk us through

Similar wording

the plans as i walk through each sheet or if you can tell us what we're looking at and explain

Similar wording

the project um we won't start here let's just we can start here yes so um this is uh as

Similar wording

that we mentioned it's a nine uh nine single families uh of a similar nature they're identical

Similar wording

in uh in design uh and materials uh they just repeat um five of them would be um facing

Similar wording

susquehanna and four of them will be facing fair hill what you're seeing on the screen now is a

Similar wording

site map and transportation uh we worked with the neighborhood to kind of go through and and and

Similar wording

verify that we that the site is you know is is fit to accommodate those nine new uh new homes with

Similar wording

respect to transportation and amenities inside amenities looking at looking at

Similar wording

the stores around looking at the at the religious assemblies around and you know

Similar wording

kind of making sure that it's a good fit went ahead and looked at the at you know

Similar wording

what does the site does what does the building do to the to the surrounding

Similar wording

kind of neighbors with respect to Sun and light those are to to fit within the

Similar wording

the philly fabric you know it's a three-story uh single family so light and shadows you know don't

Similar wording

really affect when you're in the three-story especially on white streets like so squahana

Similar wording

um you see in here existing uh conditions existing uh kind of side pictures as you see on the upper

Similar wording

left you could see there is an existing one story uh one story kind of a garage mechanic store that

Similar wording

is uh there will be uh demolished um and then in the rest of the picture you could see it's kind

Similar wording

And then in the rest of the picture, you could see it's kind of an open lot, kind of with a fenced open lot that is fenced. That's the corner. Let's go down. This is a little pixelated, but that's really the corner looking from above.

Similar wording

of an open LUT

Similar wording

if you go to the next one we have a zoomed in on that one so as you could see we have five homes

Similar wording

facing sasquahanna four homes facing fair hill they will be identical in in in architecture

Similar wording

with respect to to the program they're going to be a three bedroom two and a half baths

Similar wording

they will have their front kind of garden and a front parking and a back and a rear yard to each

Similar wording

and every one of them um as you see here we have two colors we have the color that is blue um kind

Similar wording

of showing one program and then we have that kind of uh pinkish peach color that's the same uh it's

Similar wording

the same typology the only difference is that uh building f has bay windows building e excuse me

Similar wording

has bay windows um but the program is the same it's about the same house it's a corner one so

Similar wording

you get kind of you know a little bit more light uh going through the plants we'll try to maintain

Similar wording

it uh a very simple very feeling like uh wrong where you kind of you come up the stairs you

Similar wording

arrive at your common uh common floor plan living kitchen and then we inserted a half bath

Similar wording

uh so you know so you don't have to go up or down uh for uh you know a quick bathroom break um

Similar wording

and going to the second floor if you stay on that one darwin it it doesn't really matter the same

Similar wording

but on the second floor we have a front and rear bedroom i'm kind of sharing a bathroom in the

Similar wording

center of the floor um then we would have the washer dryer on that floor on the floor as well

Similar wording

we're going to have a side by side and then just simple closets there's also a whole closet for

Similar wording

towels and linens and such uh and then the third floor uh you kind of arrive at the master so the

Similar wording

master is a little bigger it has the entire front section of the of the structure um dedicated you

Similar wording

know for uh for a bed and a little sofa probably you know a a baby bed if needed um and then the

Similar wording

rear would be um a bigger master bathroom uh which is kind of you know it's kind of uh kind of nice

Similar wording

to have a whole full bathroom for the master um going up you would arrive at the roof deck

Similar wording

um and the roof deck is common so everybody that visits the house uh kids and family could arrive

Similar wording

at the at the roof deck without interrupting the master so it's you know it's kind of uh

Similar wording

it's nice for entertainment um um the basement currently is is is just for utilities we're

Similar wording

going minus 4 and a half minus 4 11 underground so it's not really buried underground but there

Similar wording

is no program uh proposed currently it's just for utilities and and probably trash as well

Similar wording

um there is enough kind of head clearance to store trash until uh till trash day uh when it would be

Similar wording

brought out there is a backyard there is a front yard as well but i'm i'm anticipating people to

Similar wording

use the basement you know to have their trash bins this is about the same house with the exception

Similar wording

that that uh this one is a corner one so it has bay windows besides that it's the same program

Similar wording

it's the same plan um so yeah uh that is the section if you could zoom in a little bit i

Similar wording

think that it's important to know that the first floor is elevated um to accommodate for a uh you

Similar wording

know for a basement that is not fully done um and doesn't kind of you know bury you on the ground

Similar wording

there is still no program there but it's just important you know to not dig too much um in our

Similar wording

in our fabric in our street kind of fabric um let's go on the building is is 3710 uh so it's

Similar wording

within uh to the roof line so it's within kind of you know the uh the typical philadelphia 38 feet

Similar wording

of fruit roof height um let's go down darwin please um and these are just kind of artistic

Similar wording

celebration uh showing the materiality um we worked with the neighborhood they it's just a

Similar wording

fairly brick you know kind of a structure where you have a little bit of siding um i'm surrounded

Similar wording

there they kind of gave us nice comments about the fact that they don't want to see metal siding

Similar wording

they want to see something more i'm more earthy more kind of you know woody and cozy so we're

Similar wording

going with some wood siding in you know in kind of a wood color um um and then you could see here

Similar wording

you have kind of a front loading parking adjacent to uh to a greenery space so each home would have

Similar wording

parking and then a nice kind of batch of of greenery to allow for a front tree uh besides

Similar wording

the street tree this is kind of you know personal private tree for those homeowners

Similar wording

um besides the backyard they're going to have more trees but a little bit kind of a streetscape um

Similar wording

kind of prompts you know to to to um to have a nice kind of a pedestrian walk on that street um

Similar wording

that is the corner so that's how kind of the corners uh appears we have the you see we try

Similar wording

that is the corner so that's how kind of the corners uh appears we have the

Similar wording

to make this as kind of a continuous design kind of a cluster so you feel cozy you feel part of the

Similar wording

neighbors you know so kind of neighbors could see that it's you know it's not uh kind of a mishmash

Similar wording

mishmash it's it's all together we'll build together um and we'll create a coherent look

Similar wording

for that corner um that is the elevation from susquehanna avenue um similarly showing brick you

Similar wording

know a little bit of brick design some exterior lights um um kind of you know big big windows but

Similar wording

but not you know not overwhelming not nothing uh nothing floor to ceiling or anything like that um

Similar wording

There we have it, thank you, thank you, thank you.

Similar wording

Now, Mr. Chairman, members of the board, again, we ended up with refusals because we are reconfiguring

Similar wording

four lots into 10.

Similar wording

Technically, right, because we have four different lots in our subdivision created 10, we actually

Similar wording

generated 20 refusals.

Similar wording

on this application but they boil down to four parts we have one a contextual setback depth

Similar wording

in the RSA 5 district right where it's we're supposed to just have zero feet per setback

Similar wording

in other words no setback but because we provide one we got that refusal um second because we're

Similar wording

in our RSA five district or partially in RSA five district,

Similar wording

our setback is considered a front yard

Similar wording

and therefore parking is not allowed.

Similar wording

The other two dimensional refusal centers around the fact

Similar wording

that because we're partially in our RM one district

Similar wording

and partially in a CMX one district,

Similar wording

those refusals centered around locked area.

Similar wording

So two of those concerns,

Similar wording

are dealing with the fact that we're partially in RSA 5,

Similar wording

and the other two are dealing with lot error.

Similar wording

Now, if you look at Exhibit 6,

Similar wording

you can go there.

Similar wording

I think we can get a better idea of what our dilemma is.

Similar wording

I started off with purple, so you notice this is one of our lots.

Similar wording

That's lot one, we'll start with the purple, lot two, our CMX one lot, and this is our RSA five lot.

Similar wording

We're combining all four lots and subdividing them into 10 lots.

Similar wording

And let's go down to nine, right?

Similar wording

As you can see, you know, that's our two lots here, our two large lots above,

Similar wording

and it's going to ultimately be all of these laws now all together

Similar wording

this comprises it makes up over 12 400 square feet of of of land and it's vacant today

Similar wording

which is something that we all have seen and is quite noticeable when you look when you drive by

Similar wording

and see the blight that is there now because of this I think the the parcels

Similar wording

itself have been have created a quagmire because you have a RM1 RSA 5

Similar wording

and a Samnex one which creates the conflict in consolidating any one of these parcels let alone

Similar wording

all four um now with respects to the front yard and the Parkinson's we ask that the board grant

Similar wording

our application because of this unique conflict the RSA 5 front yard requirement is contextual

Similar wording

like I mentioned in other words the zoning examiner is required to create a setback based on the

Similar wording

adjacent buildings here there are no adjacent buildings so the setback is zero we're proposing

Similar wording

18 feet because and because our setback exceeds zero zero that's why we have the refuse

Similar wording

now we're presenting that because we want to provide park now

Similar wording

Now, if we can, I think we noticed that there was a no parking sign here.

Similar wording

sign here i think it's only for traps but even better yet i can

Similar wording

I think it's only for trash, but even better yet.

Similar wording

get the board to indulge me let's actually go on google maps

Similar wording

oops

Similar wording

so google maps this is 521 susquehanna you see

Similar wording

this is fair hill but let me just go back on susquehanna and start there

Similar wording

there's massive

Similar wording

crowded parking here

Similar wording

truck parking

Similar wording

more truck parts right right darwin we don't see any oh you don't see any of this let me just see

Similar wording

the one you had we'll do that again darwin let me ask you a question how much longer do you think

Similar wording

you'll be with this oh I could speed it up give me yeah I'm just gonna be just

Similar wording

gonna be maybe five six minutes okay that's all that's all because I what I

Similar wording

does everyone see this the Google Maps now we see that right okay so this is

Similar wording

what i wanted to show i wanted to this is this is susquehanna as you can see the blight

Similar wording

let's just walk down fair fair hill you see

Similar wording

the pickup trucks see the panel truck you also see this truck with its hood up right

Similar wording

all in support of this garage which is the one of the properties that we own that we are going to

Similar wording

now change it to an allowable use of single family homes right so we are changing all of this

Similar wording

but i also want the board to understand if there's issues of uh curb cuts and taking parking spaces

Similar wording

is we do have, as you walk down the street,

Similar wording

we do have off-street parking.

Similar wording

And off-street parking, we believe that we're providing,

Similar wording

will not create any negative issues onto the property.

Similar wording

So having said that, you know,

Similar wording

we do submit that because the garage will be demolished,

Similar wording

that use will be gone, right?

Similar wording

The truck parking will also be gone, right?

Similar wording

And the fact that we are providing this 18 foot setback

Similar wording

in order to provide our own parking,

Similar wording

we believe that we have no negative impact

Similar wording

in providing such as you see in our application.

Similar wording

Now, with respect to the lot area,

Similar wording

just want the board to just go back here.

Similar wording

We have what you will call a, we're required to have 1440, as we all know, and parcel

Similar wording

So E is actually short by 180 square feet, and the following parcels are about the same.

Similar wording

We're short about 226.

Similar wording

We asked that you grant our application because, again, we were asked to have our setback at zero.

Similar wording

And what we're realizing is that you can see here.

Similar wording

We are presenting open space in the rear.

Similar wording

We are providing backyards.

Similar wording

And because we're providing backyards as well as parking,

Similar wording

we believe that we're creating a natural lot with a single-family home

Similar wording

that is only missing approximately, you know, any less than 200 feet on average.

Similar wording

square feet and we're doing that to provide both a front yard with parking and a rear yard

Similar wording

both a front yard with parking and a rear door.

Similar wording

And we believe that will give us the best use,

Similar wording

the best possible scenario for all.

Similar wording

And we do submit that by doing that,

Similar wording

we're not creating a negative impact as a result.

Similar wording

All in all, that gives us,

Similar wording

if you look at all the lots together,

Similar wording

We have, again, over 12,000 square feet of redevelopment land that we're proposing, and if you take that average, right, we're not that far off with 1440.

Similar wording

so with that i'm i we did meet with the community the community did give us a letter of not

Similar wording

opposition um we did have the our meeting in july of this year and and with that i would like to

Similar wording

bring the owner uh mr natty levy so so so let me tell you where where i stand with this um

Similar wording

uh i'm going to bring the owner on he'll adopt it then we're going to break and i'm bringing

Similar wording

you back at two o'clock and the reason being is we have a very long day ahead of us and i don't

Similar wording

want anybody to think well we have to be done questions in like two or three minutes so what

Similar wording

i'll do is bring the owner on you're going to top top the testimony we'll come back at two o'clock

Similar wording

and we'll finish this first and then we'll go to our two o'clock first okay so bring your client

Similar wording

on all right mr levi mr chairman member of the board sir could you please state and spell your

Similar wording

name for the stenographer netanelle levy n-e-t-a-n-e-l last name l-e-v-i you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth i do council natty have you heard everything

Similar wording

that was the statements that were made today in support of this application i did and if given a

Similar wording

chance would you uh made the same statements i would therefore is it safe to say that you would

Similar wording

have you will adopt my statements and all the statements made today in support of this

Similar wording

application yes i do all right all right all right so so here's here's where we are listen

Similar wording

up for everybody we're going to break at two o'clock we'll come back we'll finish this case

Similar wording

and then we'll start at two o'clock list sorry okay thank you everybody so there's one case left

Similar wording

right this is it and then uh we'll we'll come back at two chair i'm sorry to interrupt this

Similar wording

is ian hegarty um we have a request from the rco representative to make their statement now so they

Similar wording

don't have to wait until 2 p.m would you be willing to indulge that if they could yes yes all right

Similar wording